产品伤害危机预期下的最优动态广告策略

doi:10.16381/j.cnki.issn1003-207x.2019.0253

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 企业在实际经营过程中不可避免的会遭遇产品伤害危机(Product-Harm Crisis)，危机的发生会使商誉受到折损。因此，本文旨在研究当企业预期到可能会发生产品伤害危机时的动态广告策略。为此，首先利用随机到达过程刻画危机的发生，并在此基础上建立危机影响下的动态广告模型。其次运用贝尔曼动态规划原理得到了制造商和零售商在集中、分散以及成本分担决策模式下的最优广告和成本分担策略。最后通过对结果的研究分析可以发现：产品伤害危机的预期会改变供应链成员的时间偏好，使供应链成员更重视当前而不是未来的利润；当危机发生率以及商誉折损率增大时，制造商应减少危机前的广告投入；危机发生率以及商誉折损率会影响零售商危机前的成本分担策略，但影响的结果取决于双方危机前后边际利润的情况；成本分担策略依然能够提高供应链双方的广告投入，从而提高商誉、市场需求和双方的利润，最终实现帕累托改进。

关键词: 产品伤害危机；随机最优控制；动态合作广告；微分博弈；成本分担

Abstract: It is inevitable for any company to faceProduct-Harm Crisis which could inflict damage on goodwill.The deep causes of Product-Harm Crisis root in the design and production phases before the products are launched and cannot be changed or influenced by the firm.Therefore, it aims to explore the optimal dynamic advertising strategies when supply chain members envision the occurrence of Product-Harm Crisis by formulating a dynamic advertising model with the occurrence process of crisis. Using the Bellman continuous dynamic programming theory, the optimal advertising and cost-sharing strategies of both manufacturer and retailer under centralized, decentralized and cost-sharing pattern are obtained respectively.The main conclusions and managerial insight obtained from this paper are as follows:

Key words: product-harm crisis; stochastic optimal control;dynamic cooperative advertising; differential game; cost-sharing

中图分类号:

F224.3

王威昊, 马德清, 胡劲松. 产品伤害危机预期下的最优动态广告策略[J]. 中国管理科学, 2022, 30(2): 204-216.

WANG Wei-hao, MA De-qing, HU Jin-song. Optimal Dynamic Advertising Strategies with Presence of Probable Product-Harm Crisis[J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2022, 30(2): 204-216.

参考文献

［1］ Johnson B. Samsung overtakes P&G as World’s largest advertiser［EB/OL］.(2018-12-3)［2019- 2-19］.https://adage.com/article/news/globalmarketers2018-tktk/315743/
［2］ Zhang Juan, Gou Qinglong, Liang Liang, et al. Supply chain coordination through cooperative advertising with reference price effect［J］. Omega,2013,41(2):345-353.
［3］ Jrgensen S, Taboubi S, Zaccour G. Cooperative advertising in a marketing channel［J］. Journal of Optimization Theory & Applications,2001,110 (1):145-158.
［4］张庶萍,张世英.基于微分对策的供应链合作广告决策研究［J］.控制与决策,2006,21(2):153-157 +162.Zhang Shuping, Zhang Shiying. Dynamic cooperative advertising strategies based on differential games in a supply chain［J］. Control and Decision,2006,21(2):153-157+162.
［5］傅强,曾顺秋.纵向合作广告的微分对策模型研究［J］.系统工程理论与实践,2007, 27(11):26-33.Fu Qiang, Zeng Shunqiu. Differential game models of the vertical cooperative advertising［J］. Systems Engineering Theory & Practice,2007,27 (11):26-33.
［6］聂佳佳,熊中楷.多种广告媒体下纵向合作广告的微分对策模型［J］.管理科学学报,2010,13(5)：1-10.Nie Jiajia, Xiong Zhongkai. Differential game models of vertical cooperative advertising with multiple advertising media［J］. Journal of Management Sciences in China,2010,13(5):1-10.
［7］熊中楷,聂佳佳,熊榆.零售商竞争下纵向合作广告的微分对策模型［J］.管理科学学报,2010,13(6):11-22.Xiong Zhongkai, Nie Jiajia, Xiong Yu. Vertical cooperative advertising model with competing retailers in supply chains with stochastic differential game［J］. Journal of Management Sciences in China,2010,13(6):11-22.
［8］聂佳佳.供应链竞争下基于微分对策的合作广告模型［J］.系统管理学报,2011, 20(5):578-588.Nie Jiajia. Cooperative advertising model with competing supply chains with differential game［J］. Journal of Systems & Management,2011,20(5): 578-588.
［9］许明辉,刘晚霞.制造商竞争环境下基于要素品牌战略的动态合作广告研究［J］.管理工程学报,2019,33(3):162-169.Xu Minghui, Liu Wanxia. Dynamic cooperative advertising with competitive manufacturers based on ingredient branding strategy［J］. Journal of Industrial Engineering and Engineering Management,2019,33(3):162-169.
［10］张智勇,李华娟,杨磊,等.基于微分博弈的双渠道广告合作协调策略研究［J］.控制与决策,2014(5):873-879.Zhang Zhiyong, Li Huajuan, Yang Lei, et al. Dual-channel coordination strategies on advertising cooperation based on differential game［J］. Control and Decision,2014(5):873-879.
［11］张旭梅,陈国鹏.存在品牌差异的双渠道供应链合作广告协调模型［J］.管理工程学报,2016, 30(2):152-159.Zhang Xumei, Chen Guopeng. Coordination model for cooperative advertising in dual-channel supply chain under product brand differentiation［J］. Journal of Industrial Engineering and Engineering Management,2016,30(2):152-159.
［12］林晶,王健,郑敏.买方抗衡势力下双渠道促销合作微分博弈研究［J］.中国管理科学,2019,27(9):80- 92.Lin Jing, Wang Jian, Zheng Min. Research on dual-channel promotion cooperation and differential game under buyer’s countervailing power［J］. Chinese Journal of Management Science,2019,27(9):80- 92.
［13］马德青,胡劲松.消费者展厅行为和参考质量效应对O2O供应链动态运营策略的影响［J］.中国管理科学,2020,DOI:10.16381/j.cnki.issn1003-207x.2019.0649.Ma Deqing, Hu Jinsong. Study on the dynamic operation and marketing strategies of O2O supply chain considering consumers’ showrooming and reference quality effect［J］. Chinese Journal of Management Science,2020,DOI:10.16381/j.cnki.issn1003-207x.2019.0649.
［14］陈东彦,于浍,侯玲.考虑延时效应的供应链动态合作广告策略研究［J］.管理科学学报,2017,20(9):30-40.Chen Dongyan, Yu Hui, Hou Ling. Dynamic coo-perative advertising strategies in a supply chain with lagged effect［J］. Journal of Management Sciences in China,2017,20(9):30-40.
［15］于浍,陈东彦,黄春丽.考虑延时和记忆效应的供应链广告策略［J］.控制与决策,2018,33(10): 1871-1878.Yu Hui, Chen Dongyan, Huang Chunli. Advertising strategies for supply chain with lagged and memory effects［J］. Control and Decision,2018, 33(10):1871-1878.
［16］曹端阳,肖剑,张旭梅.延时效应下的双渠道供应链合作广告策略［J］.计算机集成制造系统,2020,26(8):2253-2265.Cao Duanyang, Xiao Jian, Zhang Xumei. Cooperative advertising strategy in dual-channel supply chain with lagged effect［J］. Computer Integrated Manufacturing Systems,2020,26(8): 2253-2265.
［17］ Siomkos G J, Kurzbard G. The hidden crisis in product-harm crisis management［J］. European Journal of Marketing,1994,28(2):30-41.
［18］崔保军. 产品伤害危机情境下消费者感知风险的研究述评与展望［J］.商业经济与管理,2015(4):63-73.Cui Baojun. A review of literature on consumers perceived risk in situations of product-harm crisis and prospect［J］. Journal of Business Economics, 2015(4):63-73.
［19］ Wei Jiuchang, Zhao Ming, Wang Fei, et al.An empirical study of the volkswagen crisis in China: Customers’ information processing and behavioral intentions［J］. Risk Analysis,2016,36(1):114-129.
［20］王晓玉,晁钢令,吴纪元.产品伤害危机及其处理过程对消费者考虑集的影响［J］.管理世界,2006(5):86-95.Wang Xiaoyu, Chao Gangling, Wu Jiyuan. The effect of product-harm crises and the process of tiding over them on consumer consideration set［J］. Management World,2006(5):86-95.
［21］范春梅,叶登楠,李华强.产品伤害危机中消费者应对行为的形成机制研究—基于PADM理论视角的扎根分析［J］.管理评论,2019,31(8):230- 239.Fan Chunmei, Ye Dengnan, Li Huaqiang. The formation mechanism of consumers’ coping behavior in product harm crisis—A Grounded research based on PADM theory［J］. Management review,2019,31(8):230-239.
［22］马宝龙,李飞,王高,等.产品伤害危机对品牌绩效指标的影响研究—基于随机模型方法的实证分析［J］.预测,2010,29(4):9-16.Ma Baolong, Li Fei, Wang Gao, et al. Effect of production harm crisis on brand performance—A empirical study based on stochastic models’ method［J］. Forecasting,2010,29(4):9-16.
［23］吴剑琳,古继宝,代祺.产品伤害危机对购买意愿的影响:消费者人口统计特征的调节作用—以丰田召回事件为例［J］.软科学,2012,26(2):25-29.Wu Jianlin, Gu Jibao, Dai Qi. The impact of product-harm crisis on purchase intention: mode- rating effects of personal characteristics of consumers—the example of Toyota recalls［J］. Soft Science,2012,26(2):25-29.
［24］ Laufer D, Coombs W T. How should a company respond to a product harm crisis? The role of corporate reputation and consumer-based cues［J］. Business Horizons,2006,49(5):379-385.
［25］ Vassilikopoulou A, Siomkos G, Chatzipanagiotou K, et al.Product-harm crisis management: Time heals all wounds?［J］.Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services,2009,16(3):174-180.
［26］陈锟,彭怡,寇纲,等.产品伤害危机的营销补救策略优化［J］.系统工程理论与实践,2012,32(5):919-927.Chen Kun, Peng Yi, Kou Gang, et al. Optimization of marketing retrieving strategies during product harm crisis［J］. Systems Engineering Theory& Practice,2012,32(5):919-927.
［27］陈斯允,卫海英,冉雅璇,等.“重振旗鼓”还是“重蹈覆辙”—新起点思维与品牌危机类型对消费者宽恕的影响［J］.南开管理评论,2020,23(4): 49-59+83.Chen Siyun, Wei Haiying, Ran Yaxuan, et al. Rise from the ashes or repeat the past? the effects of fresh start mindset and brand crisis type on consumer forgiveness［J］.Nankai Business Review,2020,23(4):49-59+83.
［28］ JrgensenS, Zaccour G. Equilibrium pricing and advertising strategies in a marketing channel［J］. Journal of Optimization Theory and Applications, 1999, 102(1):111-125.
［29］ Crettez B, Hayek N, Zaccour G. Existence, and uniqueness of optimal dynamic pricing and advertising controls without concavity［J］. Operations Research Letters,2018,46(2):199-204.
［30］ Heerde H V, Helsen K, Dekimpe M G. The impact of a product-harm crisis on marketing effectiveness［J］. Marketing Science,2007,26(2): 230-245.
［31］ Thirumalai S, Sinha K K. Product recalls in the medical device industry: An empirical exploration of the sources and financial consequences［J］. Management Science, 2011, 57(2):376-392.
［32］ Jrgensen S, Zaccour G. Differential Games in Marketing［M］. New York: Springer, 2004.
［33］ Kamien M I, Schwartz N L. Dynamic optimization: The calculus of variation and optimal control in economics and management 2nd Edition［M］. North-Holland: Elsevier Science, 1993.
［34］ Yeung D W K, Petrosyan L A. Cooperative stochastic differential games［M］. New York: Springer,2006.

[1]	李剑，易兰，肖瑶. 信息不对称下基于区块链驱动的供应链减排信息共享机制研究[J]. 中国管理科学, 2021, 29(10): 131-139.
[2]	魏尉，梅姝娥，仲伟俊. 社交媒体中企业分享奖励营销模式研究[J]. 中国管理科学, 2021, 29(10): 213-223.
[3]	冯海荣, 曾银莲, 周杰. 碳交易机制下零售商合作的费用分配研究[J]. 中国管理科学, 2021, 29(5): 108-116.
[4]	高岩. 智能电网实时电价社会福利最大化模型的研究[J]. 中国管理科学, 2020, 28(10): 201-209.
[5]	项寅. 不对称信息下反恐阻止网络设计[J]. 中国管理科学, 2020, 28(9): 188-198.
[6]	马咏, 何正文, 郑维博. 基于柔性资源约束的前摄性项目调度优化研究[J]. 中国管理科学, 2020, 28(7): 220-230.
[7]	杨乃定, 王京北, 张延禄, 宋悦. 考虑自适应行为的研发网络风险传播模型构建及仿真[J]. 中国管理科学, 2020, 28(3): 182-190.
[8]	王先甲, 刘佳. 基于合作博弈模型的公共河流水资源分配方案研究[J]. 中国管理科学, 2020, 28(1): 1-9.
[9]	杨乃定, 刘慧, 张延禄, 李芮萌. 考虑项目关联关系的R&D网络风险传播建模与仿真[J]. 中国管理科学, 2019, 27(10): 179-188.
[10]	杨松, 庄晋财, 王爱峰. 惩罚机制下农产品质量安全投入演化博弈分析[J]. 中国管理科学, 2019, 27(8): 181-190.
[11]	项寅. 基于双层规划的反恐应急设施选址模型及算法[J]. 中国管理科学, 2019, 27(7): 147-157.
[12]	王荧, 王应明. 基于未来效率的兼顾公平与效率的资源分配DEA模型研究——以各省碳排放额分配为例[J]. 中国管理科学, 2019, 27(5): 161-173.
[13]	郭本海, 储佳娜, 赵荧梅. 核心企业主导下乳制品全产业链质量管控GERT网络模型[J]. 中国管理科学, 2019, 27(1): 120-130.
[14]	单而芳, 梁莉敏, 张广. 基于限制博弈的具有容量限制的易腐品联合运输费用分摊问题[J]. 中国管理科学, 2018, 26(9): 97-105.
[15]	金亮. 不对称信息下“农超对接”供应链定价及合同设计[J]. 中国管理科学, 2018, 26(6): 153-166.