疫情爆发初期应急采购最优启动时间点选择

doi:10.16381/j.cnki.issn1003-207x.2021.2631

Abstract

Abstract:

Rational allocation of emergency medical resource is crucial for epidemic prevention and control. However， in the early stage of the epidemic， emergency departments are often difficult to accurately predict its spread trend in the first time， and need to update and revise the prediction results through continuous learning of new information in the later stage. Thus， early launch of emergency procurement plans may lead to idle resources due to the inaccurate prediction of epidemic evolution， and late launch may lead to the risk of resource shortage. In this context， optimal selection of the start time of resource procurement becomes an important decision problem faced by emergency departments.Since the 21st century， emergency procurement problems has been widely concerned and deeply studied by scholars. However， most of the existing studies only focus on supplier selection， order allocation， contract design problems under the background of natural disasters such as earthquake and hurricane， but little attention is paid to the start point selection of emergency procurement under the background of epidemic. In particular， compared with natural disasters， the evolution of the epidemic has dynamic and time-varying characteristics， which brings new challenges to the procurement optimization problem.In this context， a novel emergency procurement optimization problem is present under the epidemic situation. Firstly， in order to obtain the optimal start time of emergency procurement， an epidemic observation stopping time （or emergency start-up time） judgment rules is proposed， and the boundary characteristics and influencing factors of the optimal start-up time are analyzed. Secondly， in order to obtain an effective supplier selection and order allocation scheme after starting procurement， a novel mixed integer programming model is proposed after comprehensively considering the differences of each supplier in order quantity， supply capacity， procurement lead time and shortage risk. Thirdly， the above two problems are integrated and a data-driven framework model of emergency procurement is constructed based on the optimization process of “epidemic prediction， emergency response effect comparison， stop-judgment and parameter update”. Finally， the model is applied in a case study， and the simulation results show that the data-driven model not only ensures that procurement decisions are based on epidemic data， but also ensures that epidemic data are updated in real time.

Key words: epidemic, relief procurement, data-driven, optimal stopping

CLC Number:

O225

Yin Xiang. Optimal Selection of Relief Procurement Time in the Early Stage of Epidemics[J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2024, 32(2): 210-220.

Figures/Tables 11

当前决策期 $τ 1$	未来决策期 $τ 2$
当前决策期 $τ 1$	$τ 2$ =2	$τ 2$ =3	$τ 2$ =4	$τ 2$ =5
$τ 1$ =1	$F (1 → 2)$	$F (1 → 3)$	$F (1 → 4)$	$F (1 → 5)$
$τ 1$ =2	×	$F (2 → 3)$	$F (2 → 4)$	$F (2 → 5)$
$τ 1$ =3	×	×	$F (3 → 4)$	$F (3 → 5)$
$τ 1$ =4	×	×	×	$F (4 → 5)$
$τ 1$ =5=\|T\|	×	×	×	×

求解算法

1. 初始化模型输入参数，令 $τ 1 = 1, τ 2 = 2, τ * = ?$

2. While $τ 1 < | T | - 1$

3. 预测后续 ${τ 1 + 1, …, | T |}$ 期的资源需求 $D F (τ 1)$ ，通过求解“模型1”并结合式(15)计算在 $τ 1$ 启动应急采购时整个疫情期的系统成本 $F (τ 1)$

4. While $τ 2 < | T |$

5. 依据资源预测需求 $D F (τ 1)$ ，通过求解“模型1”并结合式(15)计算在 $τ 2$ 启动应急采购时整个疫情期的系统成本 $F (τ 1 → τ 2)$

6. 令 $τ 2 = τ 2 + 1$

7. End

8. If $F (τ 1) ≤ F (τ 1 → τ 2)$ ，其中 $τ 2 ∈ {τ 1 + 1, …, | T | - 1}$

9. 停止疫情观测，记录最优的停止观测时间为 $τ * = τ 1$ ，退出while循环并转到第14行

10. Else

11. 令 $τ 1 = τ 1 + 1$ ，令 $τ 2 = τ 1 + 1$ ，继续观测疫情，更新传染病模型参数并继续迭代

12. End

13. End

14. If $τ * = | T | - 1$ 且 $I V τ * ≥ D F | T | (τ *) + Θ$

不启动应急采购

15 Else

16. 将最优采购启动时间 $τ *$ 带入模型，算出最优的供应商选择和订单分配方案 $x (τ) 、 y (τ)$

17.End

情境

特点

计算方法

参数说明

情境1

(预测偏小)

各期预测需求小于真实值，但偏差不断减少

D F t (τ 1) = α + (1 - α) ? τ 1 | T | ? D R t

$τ 1$ :决策期{1,2，…，|T|-1}; |T|:疫情初期时长

$D F t (τ 1)$ ： $τ 1$ 预测到 $t ∈ {τ + 1, …, | T |}$ 期的需求

$D R t$ ：各个时期t的真实需求

$α, β$ ：预测偏差系数， $α = 0.5, β = 1.5$

情境2

(预测偏大)

各期预测需求大于真实值，但偏差不断减少

D F t (τ 1) = β - (β - 1) ? τ 1 | T | ? D R t

需求	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	8	9	10
$D R t$	45	62	121	198	258	363	425	495	572	618
$D F t ∈ {2 . . . 10} (τ 1 = 1)$		34	67	109	142	200	234	272	315	340
$D F t ∈ {3 . . . 10} (τ 1 = 2)$			73	119	155	218	255	297	343	371
$D F t ∈ {4 . . . 10} (τ 1 = 3)$				129	168	236	276	322	372	402
$D F t ∈ {5 . . . 10} (τ 1 = 4)$					181	254	298	347	400	433
$D F t ∈ {6 . . . 10} (τ 1 = 5)$						272	319	371	429	464
$D F t ∈ {7 . . . 10} (τ 1 = 6)$							340	396	458	494
$D F t ∈ {8 . . . 10} (τ 1 = 7)$								421	486	525
$D F t ∈ {9,10 \|} (τ 1 = 8)$									515	556
$D F t ∈ {10} (τ 1 = 9)$										587

需求	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	8	9	10
$D R t$	45	62	121	198	258	363	425	495	572	618
$D F t ∈ {2 . . . 10} (τ 1 = 1)$		90	175	287	374	526	616	718	829	896
$D F t ∈ {3 . . . 10} (τ 1 = 2)$			169	277	361	508	595	693	801	865
$D F t ∈ {4 . . . 10} (τ 1 = 3)$				267	348	490	574	668	772	834
$D F t ∈ {5 . . . 10} (τ 1 = 4)$					335	472	553	644	744	803
$D F t ∈ {6 . . . 10} (τ 1 = 5)$						454	531	619	715	773
$D F t ∈ {7 . . . 10} (τ 1 = 6)$							510	594	686	742
$D F t ∈ {8 . . . 10} (τ 1 = 7)$								569	658	711
$D F t ∈ {9,10 \|} (τ 1 = 8)$									629	680
$D F t ∈ {10} (τ 1 = 9)$										649

s	*co_s*	*l_s*	*m_s*	*cp_s*	*up_s*	$η s$
1	0.8	1	50	14	30	3
2	0.9	2	40	13	40	1
3	1	4	50	11	70	1
4	0.5	4	60	11	60	5
5	0.9	3	40	12	55	2
6	0.8	5	60	11	50	3
7	0.8	1	70	10	55	2
8	0.9	1	30	14	25	1
9	0.8	2	40	12	40	2
10	0.7	2	20	15	35	4

$τ 1$	$F (τ 1)$	$τ 2$
		2	3	4	5	6	7	8	9
		$F (τ 1 → 2)$	$F (τ 1 → 3)$	$F (τ 1 → 4)$	$F (τ 1 → 5)$	$F (τ 1 → 6)$	$F (τ 1 → 7)$	$F (τ 1 → 8)$	$F (τ 1 → 9)$
1	4.198	4.194	4.191	4.188	4.185	4.181	4.178	4.175	4.172
2	4.405	0	4.402	4.398	4.395	4.391	4.388	4.385	11.011
3	4.612	0	0	4.609	4.605	4.601	4.598	4.594	27.481
4	5.306	0	0	0	5.303	5.299	5.547	6.113	44.980
5	5.558	0	0	0	0	5.554	5.847	20.233	61.880
6	5.760	0	0	0	0	0	6.091	34.023	78.550

$τ 1$	$F (τ 1)$	$τ 2$
		2	3	4	5	6	7	8	9
		$F (τ 1 → 2)$	$F (τ 1 → 3)$	$F (τ 1 → 4)$	$F (τ 1 → 5)$	$F (τ 1 → 6)$	$F (τ 1 → 7)$	$F (τ 1 → 8)$	$F (τ 1 → 9)$
1	7.898	7.892	7.886	7.879	7.873	7.867	68.976	139.787	221.710
2	7.689	0	7.683	7.678	7.672	7.666	59.280	127.614	206.769
3	7.477	0	0	7.471	7.466	7.460	48.086	114.044	190.327
4	7.216	0	0	0	7.211	7.205	35.868	99.470	172.985
5	6.955	0	0	0	0	6.950	24.072	85.200	155.843
6	6.744	0	0	0	0	0	12.750	71.427	138.559

IV₀	实验1	实验2		实验3		实验4
IV₀	最优采购启动时期	min(LT)	最优采购启动时期	$α$	最优采购启动时期	$β$	最优采购启动时期
500	4	1	6	0.5	6	1.5	4
1000	6	2	5	0.6	6	1.4	5
1500	6	3	4	0.7	6	1.3	5
2000	6	4	3	0.8	5	1.2	5
2500	8	5	2	0.9	5	1.1	5

References 23

1	葛洪磊，刘南. 重大传染病疫情演化情境下应急物资配置决策建模分析：以新冠肺炎疫情为例［J］. 管理工程学报， 2020， 34（3）： 214-222.
	Ge H L， Liu N. Modeling of emergency materials allocation decision-making problems based on the evolution scenarios of serious infectious disease：a case of COVID-19［J］. Journal of Industrial Engineering Management， 2020， 34（3）： 214-222.
2	Orji I J， Ojadi F. Investigating the COVID-19 pandemic's impact on sustainable supplier selection in the nigerian manufacturing Sector［J］. Computers & Industrial Engineering， 2021， 160：57-69.
3	Firouzi F， Jadidi O. Multi-objective model for supplier selection and order allocation problem with fuzzy parameters［J］. Expert Systems With Applications， 2021， 180：1-9.
4	田军，葛永玲，侯丛丛. 政府主导的基于实物期权契约的应急物资采购模型［J］. 系统工程理论与实践， 2014， 34（10）： 2582-2590.
	Tian J， Ge Y L， Hou C C. Government driving emergency supplies procurement model based on real option contract［J］. Systems Engineering-Theory & Practice， 2014， 34（10）： 2582-2590.
5	扈衷权，田军，王鹏. 政企联合储备模式下应急物资储备及采购定价研究［J］. 系统工程理论与实践， 2020， 40（12）： 3181-3193.
	Hu Z Q， Tian J， Wang P. A research on emergency supplies reserve and purchase pricing under the mode of joint reserve of governments and enterprises［J］. Systems Engineering-Theory & Practice， 2020， 40（12）： 3181-3193.
6	Wang X H， Feng L， Liang L， et al. Pre-purchasing with option contract and coordination in a relief supply chain［J］. International Journal of Production Economics， 2015， 167：170-186.
7	Wang X H， Fan Y， Liang L， et al. Augmenting fixed framework agreements in humanitarian logistics with a bonus contract［J］. Production and Operations Management， 2019， 28（8）： 1921-1938.
8	Burcu B， Deniz A. Supplier selection for framework agreements in humanitarian relief［J］. Production and Operations Management， 2014， 23（6）：1028–1041.
9	Hu S L， Dong Z J. Supplier selection and pre-positioning strategy in humanitarian relief［J］. Omega， 2019， 69：287-298.
10	张梦玲，王晶，黄钧．不确定需求下考虑供应商参与机制的应急资源配置鲁棒优化研究［J］. 中国管理科学， 2020， 28（7）：102-111.
	Zhang M L， Wang J， Huang J. Research on robust optimization of emergency resource allocation based on supplier participation mechanism under uncertain demand［J］. Chinese Journal of Management Science， 2020， 28（7）：102-111.
11	董银红，郑琪，李龙. 考虑供应风险的多源应急物资采购双层规划模型［J］. 中国管理科学， 2021， 29（11）：170-178.
	Dong Y H， Zhen Q， Li L. Bi-level programming model for multi-source emergency material procurement considering supply risk［J］. Chinese Journal of Management Science， 2021， 29（11）：170-178.
12	王新平，王海燕. 多疫区多周期应急物资协同优化调度［J］. 系统工程理论与实践， 2012， 32（5）：937-949.
	Wang X P， Wang H Y. Optimal multi-period collaborative scheduling of emergency materials for multiple epidemic areas［J］. Systems Engineering-Theory & Practice， 2012， 32（5）：937-949.
13	He Y X， Liu N. Methodology of emergency medical logistics for public health emergencies［J］. Transportation Research Part E， 2015， 79：178–200.
14	Long E F， Nohdurft E， Spinler S. Spatial resource allocation for emerging epidemics： a comparison of greedy， myopic， and dynamic policies ［J］. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management， 2018， 20（2）： 181-198.
15	Buyuktahtakon I E， Emmanuel D B. A new epidemics- logistics model insights into controlling the ebola virus disease in west africa［J］. European Journal of Operational Research， 2018， 265（3）：1046-1063.
16	Shakiba E， Osman Y O. Optimal influenza vaccine distribution with equity［J］. European Journal of Operational Research， 2020，283（7）：714-725.
17	Sanjay M， Hamed R， Masoud B， et al. A model of supply-chain decisions for resource sharing with an application to ventilator allocation to combat COVID-19［J］.Naval Research Logistics，2020，67（5）： 303-320.
18	刘明，曹杰，章定. 数据驱动的疫情应急物流网络动态调整优化［J］. 系统工程理论与实践， 2020， 40（2）： 437-448.
	Liu M， Cao J， Zhang D. Dynamic adjustment method for optimizing epidemic-logistics network based on data-driven［J］. Systems Engineering-Theory & Practice， 2020， 40（2）： 437-448.
19	于辉，江智慧. 突发事件下分阶段启动应急预案模型研究［J］. 管理工程学报， 2011， 25（1）：109-114.
	Yu H， Jiang Z H. Study of the model of activating contingency plans within disruptive incidents by stages［J］. Journal of Industrial Engineering Management， 2011， 25（1）：109-114.
20	黄星，王绍玉. 灾害应急状态终止的随机决策与仿真［J］. 哈尔滨工业大学学报， 2014， 46（4）：13-14.
	Huang X， Wang S Y. Random decision and simulation for the state termination of disaster emergency［J］. Journal of Harbin Institute of Technology， 2014， 46（4）：13-14.
21	Zhan S L， Liu N. Determining the optimal decision time of relief allocation in response to disaster via relief demand updates［J］. International Journal of Systems Science， 2016， 47（3）：509-520.
22	严阅，陈瑜，刘可伋，等. 基于一类时滞动力学系统对新型冠状病毒肺炎疫情的建模和预测［J］. 中国科学：数学， 2020， 50（3）： 385-392.
	Yan Y， Chen Y， Liu K J， et al. Modeling and prediction for the trend of outbreak of NCP based on a time-delay dynamic system［J］. Scientia Sinica Mathematica， 2020， 50（3）： 385-392.
23	王莹，张晨，陈英耀. 新型冠状病毒肺炎疫情下湖北省重症救治医疗设备配置情况［J］. 中国卫生资源， 2021， 24（3）：280-285.
	Wang Y， Zhang C， Chen Y Y. Allocation of medical equipment for severe treatment in Hubei under COVID-19［J］. Chinese Health Resources， 2021， 24（3）：280-285.

[1]	HU Hui, TANG Zi-qi, LIU Fu-xin, WANG Yu-qin, HE Xiong-fei, ZHAO Jiao. Optimization of Contactless Distribution of Medical Protective Materials During the Outbreak of Spreading Epidemic Disease [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2023, 31(5): 152-163.
[2]	LIANG Xi, CHEN Qing-qing. Study on the Major Epidemic Prevention and Control under the Mechanism of Government Dynamic Reward and Punishment [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2023, 31(3): 277-286.
[3]	Wei-jian JIN,Hao XU,Chuan-feng HUANG,Cheng-zhi JIANG. Research on Emergency Management Decision of Large-scale Epidemic Based on Prospect Theory [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2023, 31(10): 225-233.
[4]	WEN Feng-hua, SHEN Ti-yan, XING Jiang-bo, KOU Chen-huan. Urban Evidence-based Governance Mechanism of Public Health Emergencies [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2023, 31(1): 206-215.
[5]	LI Wen-li, LI Kun-peng, TIAN Qian-nan, LI Xue-song. The Research on Retail Logistics Distribution Routing Optimization Considering Order Release Dates in Epidemic Outbreak Environment [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2022, 30(9): 195-205.
[6]	SUN Yue, QIU Ruo-zhen. Support Vector Clustering-based Data-driven Robust Optimization Model for Multi-product Inventory Problem with Cross-selling [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2022, 30(2): 156-168.
[7]	CUI Wei, HAO Li-ning, MU Ren, SUN Hui-jun. A New Balance Strategy of Urban Subway Operation Under the COVID-19 Epidemic [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2022, 30(11): 321-332.
[8]	XU Kai, ZHOU Zong-fang, QIAN Qian. Study on the Contagion Mechanism of Associated Credit Risk with Double Propagation Path [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2021, 29(3): 49-58.
[9]	LIU Ming, LI Ying-zhu, CAO Jie, ZHANG Ding. An Optimal Design of Emergency Logistics Network for Epidemic Controlling based on Service Level [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2020, 28(3): 11-20.
[10]	QIAN Qian, XU Kai. Research on the Influence of Entrepreneur's Social Relations on Associated Credit Risk Contagion——An Dual-layer Network Perspective [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2020, 28(11): 35-42.
[11]	YANG Xiang-hao, DUAN Zhe-zhe, WANG Xiao-li. Enterprise Tacit Knowledge Propagation SIR Model with Consideration of Forgetting Mechanisms [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2019, 27(7): 195-202.
[12]	SUN Qi, JI Shou-feng, DONG Ming. Optimization of Distribution Service Quality with Constraints of Quality Preference for Data-driven Model [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2019, 27(6): 41-52.
[13]	RAN Xiao-bin, LIU Yue-wen, JIANG Jin-hu. Diffusion of Mobile Service Product Adoption:A Data-Driven Study [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2017, 25(9): 141-147.
[14]	ZHAO Zhi-ming, YANG Zhao-jun, WANG Miao. Investment and Financing Policy Based on Contingent Convertible Security [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2016, 24(7): 18-26.
[15]	ZHAO Zhi-ming, YANG Zhao-jun, WANG Miao. Investment and Financing Policy Based on Contingent Convertible Security [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2016, 24(7): 18-26.

Optimal Selection of Relief Procurement Time in the Early Stage of Epidemics

RichHTML

PDF (PC)

Knowledge

Abstract

Cite this article

share this article

Figures/Tables 11

References 23

Related Articles 15

Metrics

Comments

Recommended 0

s	*co_s*	*l_s*	*m_s*	*cp_s*	*up_s*	$η s$
1	0.8	1	50	14	30	3
2	0.9	2	40	13	40	1
3	1	4	50	11	70	1
4	0.5	4	60	11	60	5
5	0.9	3	40	12	55	2
6	0.8	5	60	11	50	3
7	0.8	1	70	10	55	2
8	0.9	1	30	14	25	1
9	0.8	2	40	12	40	2
10	0.7	2	20	15	35	4

s	*co_s*	*l_s*	*m_s*	*cp_s*	*up_s*	$η s$
1	0.8	1	50	14	30	3
2	0.9	2	40	13	40	1
3	1	4	50	11	70	1
4	0.5	4	60	11	60	5
5	0.9	3	40	12	55	2
6	0.8	5	60	11	50	3
7	0.8	1	70	10	55	2
8	0.9	1	30	14	25	1
9	0.8	2	40	12	40	2
10	0.7	2	20	15	35	4

s	*co_s*	*l_s*	*m_s*	*cp_s*	*up_s*	$η s$
1	0.8	1	50	14	30	3
2	0.9	2	40	13	40	1
3	1	4	50	11	70	1
4	0.5	4	60	11	60	5
5	0.9	3	40	12	55	2
6	0.8	5	60	11	50	3
7	0.8	1	70	10	55	2
8	0.9	1	30	14	25	1
9	0.8	2	40	12	40	2
10	0.7	2	20	15	35	4