主管:中国科学院
主办:中国优选法统筹法与经济数学研究会
   中国科学院科技战略咨询研究院

Price Decision-making in a Gray Market Supply Chain Considering Reference Price Effect under Quality Information Asymmetric

  • Ying Feng ,
  • Min Wei ,
  • Wenhao He ,
  • Yanzhi Zhang
Expand
  • School of Economics and Management,China University of Mining and Technology,Xuzhou 221116,China

Received date: 2021-08-09

  Revised date: 2021-11-04

  Online published: 2024-07-03

Abstract

The gray market has widely existed in many industries. Due to the lack of after-sales service and commodity reputation of gray products, consumers tend to be more sensitive to product price, and more cautious about product quality when buying gray products. Most of them will take the authorized product price in the high price market as an important price reference point, which results in the reference price effect. In addition, information asymmetry in the supply chain will lead to differences in the acquisition of product quality information between manufacturers and consumers. Therefore, manufacturers often face the choice of disclosing or concealing product quality information. A gray market supply chain composed of a manufacturer and a distributor is taken as the research object. Considering the distributor participates in speculation and the consumers’ purchase intention in the gray market is affected by the reference price effect, the influences of product quality information asymmetry on the manufacturer's disclosure strategy choice and the pricing-decision making of the gray market supply chain are explored. Firstly, taking the symmetric quality information as the benchmark, a manufacturer-led Stackelberg game model is constructed. It is found there exists a threshold of the upper limit of consumers' valuation of low-priced products, below (not below) which the gray market exists (does not exist)and the system achieves an interior point (boundary) equilibrium. In the asymmetric information scenario, there exists a unique quality disclosure threshold in the presence or the absence of the gray market, which makes the manufacturer's expected profits equal when disclosing and concealing quality. The threshold is affected by the upper limit of low-priced product valuation and the strength of reference price effect. When the gray market exists, whether the manufacturer chooses disclosure or concealment strategy, the increase of the upper valuation limit of low-priced products and the strength of the reference price effect will inhibit the gray market speculation of distributors. Information asymmetry does not necessarily benefit the manufacturer. It may benefit the manufacturer, only if the manufacturer conceals quality information. The distributor's participation in the gray market speculation will have an adverse effect on the manufacturer when the manufacturer discloses the quality, and while the quality is concealed, whether the distributor participates in the gray market speculation has no effect on the manufacturer. Through numerical simulations, sensitivity analysis of equilibrium solutions is carried out to reference price effect intensity in the case of information symmetry, and manufacturer's quality disclosure strategy and pricing decision under asymmetric information are analyzed. Then, the impacts of quality information asymmetry and distributors' participation in gray market speculation on manufacturer's profit are analyzed. The conclusions of this paper provide theoretical references for exploring the impacts of the quality information asymmetry and the reference price effect on pricing decisions of gray market supply chains, and the choice of manufacturer's disclosure strategy.

Cite this article

Ying Feng , Min Wei , Wenhao He , Yanzhi Zhang . Price Decision-making in a Gray Market Supply Chain Considering Reference Price Effect under Quality Information Asymmetric[J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2024 , 32(6) : 207 -218 . DOI: 10.16381/j.cnki.issn1003-207x.2021.1571

References

1 Shavandi H, Khaki S V, Khedmati M. Parallel importation and price competition in a duopoly supply chain[J]. International Journal of Production Research, 2015, 53(10): 3104-3119.
2 Shao J, Krishnan H, Mccormick S T. Gray markets and supply chain incentives[J]. Production & Operations Management, 2016, 25(11): 1807-1819.
3 KPMG, AGMA. Effective Channel management is critical in combating the gray market and increasing technology companies’ bottom Line[EB/OL].(2008-7-10)[2020-12-1]..
4 Shaikh T S. Warranty and price optimization in a competitive duopoly supply chain with parallel importation[J]. International Journal of Production Economics, 2016, 185: 76-88.
5 Ahmadi R, Iravani F, Mamani H. Supply chain coordination in the presence of gray markets and strategic consumers[J]. Journal of Operations Management, 2017, 26 (2): 252-272.
6 Matsui K. Gray-market trade with product information service in global supply chains[J]. International Journal of Production Economics, 2014, 147: 351-361.
7 Autrey R L, Bova F. Gray markets and multinational transfer pricing[J]. Accounting Review, 2012, 87(6): 393-421.
8 Li H, Shao J, Zhu S X. Parallel importation in a supply Chain: the impact of gray market structure[J]. International Transactions in Operational Research, 2018, 114(3): 220-241.
9 Ahmadi R, Mamani H, Iravani F. Coping with gray markets: The impact of market conditions and product characteristics[J]. Journal of Operations Management, 2015, 24 (5): 762-777.
10 Yang B R, Ahmadi R. Parallel imports: Challenges from unauthorized distribution channels[J]. Journal of Marketing Science, 2000, 19 (3): 279-294.
11 Autrey S. When gray is good: Gray markets and market-creating investments[J]. Journal of Operations Management, 2015, 24 (4): 547-559.
12 Yun S. Parallel imports, their deterrence and accommodation with service differentiation[J]. Journal of International Trade. 2017, 31 (3): 217-231.
13 Shao J, Krishnan H, McCormick S T. Gray markets and supply chain incentives[J]. Production and Operations Management, 2016, 25 (11): 1807-1819.
14 Zhang J Q. The benefits of consumer rebates: A strategy for gray market deterrence[J]. Journal of Operations Management, 2016, 251(2): 509-521.
15 杨锋,许凤妹 .灰色市场环境下的服务策略研究[J].中国管理科学,2021,29(2):9-18.
15 Yang F, Xu F M. Research on service strategy in a gray market[J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2021,29(2): 9-18.
16 胡斌,丁龙,胡森,等 .制造商售后服务质量决策对灰色市场的影响研究[J].中国管理科学,2021,29(7):46-56.
16 Hu B, Ding L, Hu S, et al. The impact of manufacturer service provision on retailer parallel importation[J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2021,29 (7): 46-56.
17 Abhishek S, Mateen A. Supply chain contracts in the presence of gray markets[J]. Decision Science, 2020, 51(1): 110-147.
18 丁龙,胡斌 .制造商RFID策略与零售商窜货策略的动态博弈分析[J].中国管理科学,2022,30(8): 82-94.
18 Ding L, Hu B. Dynamic game analysis of manufacturer RFID adoption and retailer parallel importation[J].Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2022,30(8): 82-94.
19 Su X M, Mukhopadhyay S K. Controlling power retailer’s gray activities through contract design[J]. Operations Management, 2012, 21 (1): 145–160.
20 洪定军,马永开,倪得兵 .灰色市场环境下供应链协调的补偿策略研究[J].系统工程学报,2018,33(1):103-115.
20 Hong D J, Ma Y K, Ni D B. Compensation strategy for supply chain coordination in gray markets[J]. Journal of Systems Engineering, 2018, 33(1):103-115.
21 洪定军,马永开,倪得兵 .授权分销商与灰色市场投机者的Stackelberg竞争分析[J].系统工程理论与实践,2016,36(12):3069-3078.
21 Hong D J, Ma Y K, Ni D B. Analysis of Stackelberg competition between the authorized and unauthorized distributors[J]. Systems Engineering-Theory & Practice, 2016, 36(12):3069-3078.
22 洪定军,付红,万娜娜,等 .灰色市场与制造商渠道结构选择[J].工业工程与管理,2021,26(1):61-67.
22 Hong D J, Fu H, Wan N N, et al. Gray markets and manufacturer’s channel structure selection[J]. Industrial Engineering and Management, 2021, 26(1):61-67.
23 Wu Z Q, Lu X Y. The effect of transfer pricing strategies on optimal control policies for a tax-efficient supply chain[J]. Omega, 2018, 80(3):209-219.
24 Guler M, Bilgic T, Gullu R. Joint pricing and inventory control for additive demand models with reference effects[J]. Annals of Operations Research, 2015, 226(1):255-276.
25 毕文杰,陈根宇,陈晓红 .考虑消费者双通道心理账户和参照依赖的动态定价问题研究[J].中国管理科学,2015,23(7):142-151.
25 Bi W J, Chen G Y, Chen X H. Dynamic pricing with consumers' double-entry mental accounting and reference effects[J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2015, 23(7): 142-151.
26 Zhang J Z, Gou Q L, Zhang J,et al. Supply chain pricing decisions with price reduction during the selling season[J]. International Journal of Production Research, 2014, 52(1):165-187.
27 Greenleaf E A. The impact of reference price effects on the profitability of price promotions[J]. Journal of Marketing Science, 1995, 14(1): 82-104.
28 Zhang J, Chiang W, Liang L. Strategic pricing with reference effects in a competitive supply chain[J]. Omega, 2014, 44:126-135 .
29 Wang Q, Zhao N, Wu J, et al. Optimal pricing and inventory policies with reference price effect and loss-Averse customers[J]. Omega, 2021,99:10-16.
30 林志炳 .基于制造商建议零售价的供应链定价策略[J].中国管理科学,2016,24(11):153-161.
30 Lin Z B. Pricing strategy of supply chain based on manufacturer's suggested retail price[J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2016, 24(11):153-161.
31 Zhou J D. Reference dependence and market competition[J]. Journal of Economic & Management Strategy, 2011, 20(4): 1072-1097.
32 Sun M. Disclosing multiple product and attributes[J]. Journal of Economics & Management Strategy, 2011, 20(1): 195-224.
33 Levin D, Ye L X. Quality disclosure and competition [J]. Journal of Industrial Economics, 2009, 57(1): 167-196.
34 Feng Z W, Xiao T J, Yu Y L. Quality disclosure strategy in a decentralized supply chain with consumer returns[J]. International Transactions in Operational Research, 2020, 27(4): 2139-2156.
35 邓力,赵瑞娟,郑建国,等 .双渠道供应链质量信息披露策略[J].系统管理学报,2019,28(1):141-154.
35 Deng L, Zhao R J, Zheng J G, et al. Quality disclosure strategy in dual-channel supply chain[J]. Journal of Systems & Management, 2019, 28(1):141-154.
36 蒋忠中,赵金龙,弋泽龙,等 .灰色市场下考虑非对称信息的制造商质量披露及定价策略[J].系统工程理论与实践,2020,40(7):1735-1751.
36 Jiang Z Z, Zhao J L, Yi Z L, et al. Quality disclosure and pricing strategies of the manufacturer with asymmetric information under gray market[J]. Systems Engineering-Theory & Practice, 2020, 40(7): 1735-1751.
37 Guo L. Quality disclosure formats in a distribution channel[J]. Management Science, 2009, 55(9): 1513-1526.
38 张翠华,孙莉莉 .双零售商动态博弈下分销渠道的质量信息披露策略研究[J].管理工程学报,2012,26(4):199-204.
38 Zhang C H, Sun L L. A quality disclosure strategy in a distribution channel based on two competitive retailers[J]. Journal of Industrial Engineering and Engineering Management, 2012, 26(4):199-204.
Outlines

/