在线评论回报的动态声誉机制研究

doi:10.16381/j.cnki.issn1003-207x.2019.0383

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 当前学界研究主要集中于网络评论的声誉机制或虚假评论的识别策略，好评返现可以看作是声誉的交易(消费者给予好评，商家报以返现)，而对此类带有一定贿赂性质的、诱导性的评论的声誉机制研究不多。本文以某网络购物平台2016和2017年两次追踪调查数据为样本，实证研究了好评返现是如何作用于最终声誉评价的。实证结果发现，好评返现对店铺声誉累积的实际影响并不是完全正向的，而是以店铺初始声誉等级为阈值，对于信誉等级较高的店铺(品牌商家)不敏感，对于信誉等级较低的店铺(新进卖家)比较敏感；商家是否参与好评返现并非内生于店铺的初始信誉评价，而更多的是提升信誉评分或对冲部分负面评论；消费者是否参与好评返现与其行为意愿和态度不存在显著关联，匿名环境往往使消费者更易做出内心并不认同却能获益的行为。

关键词: 好评返现；虚假评价；声誉机制

Abstract: The rewards on favorable comment can be regarded as a transaction for reputation that consumers give favorable comment and sellers give cash back as a reward. While current academic research mainly focuses on the reputation mechanism of online reviews or the identification strategy for the spam reviews, little attention has been paid to the reputation mechanism of the certain comments with the character of bribe generated by the rewards on favorable comment.

Key words: the rewards on favorable comment; spam reviews; reputation mechanism

中图分类号:

F724.6

魏瑾瑞, 王金伟. 在线评论回报的动态声誉机制研究[J]. 中国管理科学, 2022, 30(1): 252-262.

WEI Jin-rui, WANG Jin-wei. Research on Dynamic Reputation Mechanism of Online Review Return[J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2022, 30(1): 252-262.

参考文献

［1］李延喜,吴笛,肖峰雷,等.声誉理论研究述评［J］.管理评论,2010,22(10):3-11.Li Yanxi, Wu Di, Xiao Fenglei, et al. Review of reputation theory［J］. Management Review, 2010,22(10): 3-11.
［2］ Koufaris M, Hampton-Sosa W. The development of initial trust in an online company by new customers［J］. Information &Management, 2004, 41(3): 377-397.
［3］ Jarvenpaa S L, Tractinsky N, Vitale M. Consumer trust in an Internet store［J］. Information technology and management, 2000, 1(1-2): 45-71.
［4］ Liu Yong. Word of mouth for movies: Its dynamics and impact on box office revenue［J］. Journal of Marketing, 2006, 70(3): 74-89.
［5］卢向华,冯越.网络口碑的价值——基于在线餐馆点评的实证研究［J］.管理世界,2009(7):126-132+171.Lu Xianghua, Feng Yue. The value of online word of mouth——An Empirical Study Based on online restaurant reviews［J］. Management world, 2009(7): 126-132+171.
［6］ Avery C, Resnick P, Zeckhauser R. The market for evaluations［J］. American Economic Review, 1999, 89(3): 564-584.
［7］ Chen Yubo, Xie Jinhong. Online consumer review: Word-of-mouth as a new element of marketing communication mix［J］. Management Science, 2008, 54(3): 477-491.
［8］ Lee J, Lee J N. Understanding the product information inference process in electronic word-of-mouth: An objectivity-subjectivity dichotomy perspective［J］. Information & Management, 2009, 46(5): 302-311.
［9］胡磊.国外互联网信息可信性研究发展历程及特征分析［J］.中国图书馆学报,2012,38(2):100-106.Hu Lei. Development process and characteristic analysis of foreign Internet information credibility research［J］.Journal of Library Science in China, 2012,38(2): 100-106.
［10］殷国鹏.消费者认为怎样的在线评论更有用?——社会性因素的影响效应［J］.管理世界,2012(12):115-124.Yin Guopeng. What online comments do consumers think are more useful—— Influence effect of social factors［J］. Management World, 2012(12): 115-124.
［11］闫强,孟跃.在线评论的感知有用性影响因素——基于在线影评的实证研究［J］.中国管理科学,2013,21(S1):126-131.Yan Qiang, Meng Yue. Influencing factors of perceived usefulness of online reviews——An Empirical Study Based on online film reviews［J］. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2013,21 (S1): 126-131.
［12］郝媛媛,叶强,李一军.基于影评数据的在线评论有用性影响因素研究［J］.管理科学学报,2010,13(8):78-88+96.Hao Yuanyuan, Ye Qiang, Li Yijun. Study on influencing factors of online review usefulness based on film review data［J］. Journal of Management Sciences in China, 2010,13(8): 78-88+96.
［13］石文华,钟碧园,张绮.在线影评和在线短评对票房收入影响的比较研究［J］.中国管理科学,2017,25(10):162-170.Shi Wenhua, Zhong Biyuan, Zhang Qi. Comparative study on the impact of online film reviews and online short reviews on box office revenue［J］. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2017,25(10): 162-170.
［14］冯娇,姚忠.基于社会学习理论的在线评论信息对购买决策的影响研究［J］.中国管理科学,2016,24(9):106-114.Feng Jiao, Yao Zhong. Research on the impact of online comment information on purchase decision based on social learning theory［J］. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2016,24(9): 106-114.
［15］王君珺,闫强.不同热度搜索型产品的在线评论对销量影响的实证研究［J］.中国管理科学,2013,21(S2):406-411.Wang Junjun, Yan Qiang. Empirical study on the impact of online reviews of search products with different popularity on sales［J］. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2013,21(S2): 406-411.
［16］ Jindal N, Liu B. Opinion spam and analysis［C］//International Conference on Web Search and Data Mining. ACM, 2008: 219-230.
［17］ Doretto G, Chiuso A, Wu Y N, et al. Dynamic textures［J］. International Journal of Computer Vision, 2003, 51(2): 91-109.
［18］ Coviello E, Mumtaz A, Chan A B, et al. Growing a bag of systems tree for fast and accurate classification［C］//IEEE Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition. IEEE, 2012: 1979-1986.
［19］聂卉,吴毅骏.基于特征表现的虚假评论人预测研究［J］.图书情报工作,2015,59(10):102-109.Nie Hui, Wu Yijun. Research on prediction of false commentators based on characteristic performance［J］. Library and Information Service, 2015,59(10): 102-109.
［20］ Dellarocas C. Immunizing online reputation reporting systems against unfair ratings and discriminatory behavior［C］//Proceedings of the 2nd ACM Conference on Electronic Commerce. ACM, 2000: 150-157.
［21］赵宏霞,荣帅,杨皎平.在线卖方好评返现、消费者见利忘义与治理机制［J］.中国经济问题,2017(6):110-121.Zhao Hongxia, Rong Shuai, Yang Jiaoping. Online sellers’ praise, cash back, consumers’ forgetfulness for profit and governance mechanism［J］. China Economic Studies, 2017(6): 110-121.
［22］李婷婷,李艳军.“好评返现”如何影响消费者在线评论?——双通道心理账户的中介作用［J］.营销科学学报,2016,12(1):133-152.Li Tingting, Li Yanjun. How does “return of praise” affect consumers’ online comments—— Mediating role of dual channel psychological accounts［J］. Journal of Marketing Science, 2016,12(1): 133-152.
［23］宋嘉莹,王宁,杨学成.“好评返现”对用户感知评论真实性及购买意愿的影响［J］.北京邮电大学学报(社会科学版),2017,19(3):12-22.Song Jiaying, Wang Ning, Yang Xuecheng. The impact of “return of praise” on users’ perception of comment authenticity and purchase intention［J］. Journal of Beijing University of Posts and Telecommunications (Social Sciences Edition), 2017,19(3): 12-22.
［24］ Tong Y, Wang X, Teo H H. Understanding the intention of information contribution to online feedback systems from social exchange and motivation crowding perspectives［C］//2007 40th Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences (HICSS'07). IEEE, 2007: 28-28.
［25］ Ahrens J, Coyle J R, Strahilevitz M A. Electronic word of mouth: The effects of incentives on e-referrals by senders and receivers［J］. European Journal of Marketing, 2013, 47(7): 1034-1051.
［26］崔金红,汪凌韵.在线反馈系统中消费者网络口碑传播动机的实证研究［J］.现代图书情报技术,2012(10):55-60.Cui Jinhong, Wang Lingyun. Empirical study on consumers’ online word-of-mouth communication motivation in online feedback system［J］. Modern Library and Information Technology, 2012(10): 55-60.
［27］李维安,吴德胜,徐皓.网上交易中的声誉机制——来自淘宝网的证据［J］.南开管理评论,2007(5):36-46.Li Wei’an, Wu Desheng, Xu Hao. Reputation mechanism in online transactions -- Evidence from Taobao［J］. Nankai Business Review, 2007(5): 36-46.
［28］李雨洁, 廖成林, 李忆, 等. 在线商品评论可信吗——在线商品评论的偏差分析及矫正策略［J］. 营销科学学报, 2013, 9(2):111-125.Li Yujie, Liao Chenglin, Li Yi, et al. Is online commodity review credible——Deviation analysis and correction strategy of online commodity review［J］. Journal of Marketing Science, 2013, 9(2): 111-125.
［29］赵衍. 网络虚假评论研究述评［J］. 上海管理科学, 2014, 36(4).Zhao Yan. Review of research on online false comments［J］. Shanghai Management Science, 2014, 36(4).
［30］王智生,李慧颖,孙锐.在线评论有用性投票的影响因素研究——基于商品类型的调节作用［J］.管理评论,2016,28(7):143-153.Wang Zhisheng, Li Huiying, Sun Rui. Research on influencing factors of online comment usefulness voting -- regulatory effect based on commodity type［J］. Management Review, 2016,28(7): 143-153.
［31］付东普,王刊良.评论回报对在线产品评论的影响研究——社会关系视角［J］.管理科学学报,2015,18(11):1-12.Fu Dongpu, Wang Zhanliang. Research on the impact of comment return on online product comment——from the perspective of social relations［J］. Journal of Management Sciences in China, 2015,18 (11): 1-12.
［32］蒋廉雄,朱辉煌.品牌认知模式与品牌效应发生机制:超越“认知—属性”范式的理论建构［J］.管理世界,2010(9):95-115+188.Jiang Lianxiong, Zhu Huihui. Brand cognitive model and mechanism of brand effect: theoretical construction beyond “cognition attribute” paradigm［J］. Management World, 2010(9): 95-115+188.
［33］兰玉娟,佐斌.去个性化效应的社会认同模型［J］.心理科学进展,2009,17(2):467-472.Lan Yujuan, Zuo Bin. Social identity model of depersonalization effect［J］. Advances in Psychological Science, 2009,17 (2): 467-472.

[1]	张文, 王强, 马振中, 李健, 谢锐. 在线商品虚假评论发布动机及形成机理研究[J]. 中国管理科学, 2022, 30(7): 176-188.
[2]	李延晖, 廖康, 徐璐. 电商平台与服务提供商的用户隐私信息管理策略研究[J]. 中国管理科学, 2022, 30(6): 157-166.
[3]	刘仁军, 罗宇佳. 基于不同TPL权力的电商供应链决策研究[J]. 中国管理科学, 2022, 30(5): 156-166.
[4]	杨晓荣, 杜荣. IT驱动的虚拟社区知识共享对跨境电商服务质量的影响研究[J]. 中国管理科学, 2022, 30(2): 226-233.
[5]	汪旭晖, 任晓雪. 政府治理视角下平台电商信用监管的动态演化博弈研究[J]. 中国管理科学, 2021, 29(12): 29-41.
[6]	常乐, 刘长玉, 于涛, 孙振凯. 社会共治下的食品企业失信经营问题三方演化博弈研究[J]. 中国管理科学, 2020, 28(9): 221-230.
[7]	胡春华, 赵慧, 童小芹, 任剑. 推荐系统对消费者网购支出的影响研究[J]. 中国管理科学, 2020, 28(6): 158-170.
[8]	王崇, 陈大峰. O2O模式下消费者购买决策影响因素社群关系研究[J]. 中国管理科学, 2019, 27(1): 110-119.
[9]	王崇, 刘健, 吴价宝. 网络环境下消费者感知效用模型的构建与研究[J]. 中国管理科学, 2011, 19(3): 94-102.