供应商选择模型与方法综述

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 供应商选择问题是学术界和工业界十分关注的优化决策问题,许多研究者进行了并且还在继续进行相关的研究工作。本文采用分类的方法归纳了供应商选择问题的研究进展,深入分析了在不同采购策略下供应商评价准则、供应商选择模型和优化方法。本文指出了各种研究方法的优缺点、适用范围、存在的问题,并且进一步指出未来研究的方向。

关键词: 采购, 供应商选择, 采购策略, 综述

Abstract: Supplier selection is an optimal decision problem that draws attention from academic and industrial circles,and considerable research efforts have been and are continuously being devoted in the related areas.This paper categorically outlines the advances in research of supplier selections,and profoundly analyzes various purchase strategies,supplier evaluation rules,supplier selection models and the corresponding optimization approaches.Consequently,this paper identifies merits and setbacks of the approaches,their application scopes and existing problems,and further more indicates the future research directions.

Key words: purchase, supplier selection, purchase strategies, survey

中图分类号:

F830

刘晓, 李海越, 王成恩, 储诚斌. 供应商选择模型与方法综述[J]. 中国管理科学, 2004, (1): 139-148.

LIU Xiao, LI Hai-yue, Wang Cheng-en, CHU Cheng-bin. A Survey of Supplier Selection Models and Approaches[J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2004, (1): 139-148.

参考文献

[1] A.Ghobadian,A.Stainer,T.Kiss.A computerized vendor rating system[C],Proceedings of the First International Symposium on Logistics,The University of Nottingham,Nottingham,UK,July 1993,321-328.
[2] Dickson,G.,An Analysis of Vendor Selection Systems and Decisions[J].Journal of Purchasing 1996,2:28-41.
[3] C.A.Weber,J.R.Current,W.C.Benton.Vendor selection criteria and methods[J].European Journal of Operational Research,1991,50:2-18.
[4] Holt,G.D.,R.Which contractor selection methodology?[J].International Journal of Project Management 1998,16:153-164.
[5] Zeger Degraeve,Eva Labro,Filip Roodhooft.An evaluation of vendor selection models from a total cost of ownership perspective[J].European Journal of Operational Research,125:2000,34-58.
[6] Luitzen de Boer,Eva Labro.Pierangela Morlacchi,A review of methods supporting supplier selection[J].European Journal of Purchasing & Supply Management,2001,7:75-89.
[7] W.C Benton,Seunwook Park.A classification of literature on determining the lot size under quantity discounts[J].European Journal of Operational Research,1996,92:219-238.
[8] Gregory,R.E..Source selection:a matrix approach[J].European Journal of Purchasing & Supply Management,1986,22:24-29.
[9] Timmerman,E..An approach to vendor performance evaluation[J].Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management,1986,1:27-32.
[10] T.L.Saaty,J.M.Alexander.Thinking With Models:Mathematical Models in the physical,Biological and Social Sciences[M],Chapter 8,Pergamon Press,London,1981.
[11] Masood A.Badri.A combined AHP-GP model for quality control systems[J].Int.J.Production Economics,2001,72:27-40.
[12] De Boer,L.,Van der Wegen,L.,Telgen,J..Outranking methods in support of supplier selection[J].Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management,1998,4:109-118.
[13] Salleh Yahya,Brian Kingsman.Modelling a multi-objective allocation problem in a government sponsored entrepreneur development programme.[J]European Journal of Operational Research,2002,136:430-448
[14] R.Narasimhan,K.Stoynoff.Optimizing aggregate procurement allocation decisions[J].Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management,1986,22(1):23-30.
[15] Williams,R.F..Purchasing the technological product:selecting and weighting criteria for the inherently complex new product[M].University Microfilms International,Ann Arbor,MI,1984.
[16] Dae-Ho B yun.The AHP approach for selecting an automobile purchase model[J].Information & Management,2000,38:289-297.
[17] Maggie C.Y.Tam,V.M.Rao Tummala.An application of the AHP in vendor selection of a telecommunications system[J].Omega,2001,29:171-182.
[18] Morlacchi,P..Small and medium enterprises in supplier performance evaluation model and some empirical results[C].Proceedings IFPMM Summer School,August,Saltzburg,1997.
[19] Morlacchi,P..Vendor evaluation and selection:the design process and a fuzzy-hierarchical model[C].Proceedings of 8th IPSERA Conference,Dublin,1999.
[20] Soukup,W.R.,Supplier selection strategies[J].Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management,1987,23:27-32.
[21] Robert Handfied,Steven V.Walton,Robert Sroufe,Steven A.Melnyk.Applying environmental criteria to supplier assessment:A study in the application of the Analytical Hierarchy Process[J].Journal of Operational Research,2002,141:70-87.
[22] Indrani Basak.On the use of information criteria in analytic hierarchy process[J].Journal of Operational Research,2002,141:200-216.
[23] Filip Roodhooft,Jozef Konings,Vendor selection and evaluation an activity based costing approach[J].European Journal of Operational Research,1996,96:97-102.
[24] Monczka,R.M.,Trecha,S.J..cost-based supplier perpormance evaluation[J].Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management,1988,24:2-7.
[25] Smytka,D.L.,Clemens,M.W..total cost supplier selection models:a case study[J].Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management,1993,29:42-49.
[26] Pirkul,H.,and Aras,O.A..Capacitated multiple item ordering problem with quantity discount[J].IIE Transactions,1985,17(3):206-211.
[27] Colin D.Lewis.Establishing a practical range of price discount that should be aimed for when purchasing more than the EOQ,European Journal of Puchasing & Supply Management,1998,4:153-162.
[28] Faruk Guder,James L.Zydiak.Non-stationary ordering policies for multi-item inventory systems subject to a single resource constraint and quantity discounts[J].Computers Ops Res,1997,24(1):61-71.
[29] Richard J.Tersine,Samir Barman.Economic purchasing strategies for temporary price discounts[J].European Journal of Operational Research,1995,80:328-343.
[30] Timothy H.Burwell,Dinesh S.Dave,Kathy E.Fitzpatrick,Melvin R.Roy.Economic lot size model for price-dependent demand under quantity and freight discounts[J].Int.J.Production Economics,1997,48:141-155.
[31] A.A.Gaballa.Minimum cost allocation of tenders[J].Operational Research Quarterly,1974,25(3):389-398.
[32] A.C.Pan.Allocation of order quantity among suppliers[J].Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management,1989,25(3):36-39.
[33] Turner.An independent system for the evaluation of constract tenders[J].Operational Research Society,1988,39(6):551-561.
[34] S.S.Chaudhry,F.G.Forst,J.L.Zydiak.Vendor selection with price breaks[J].European Journal of Productional Research,1983,70(1):52-66.
[35] P.S.Bender,R.W.Brown,H.Isaac,J.F.Shapiro,Improving purchasing productivity at IMB with a normative decis ion support system[J].Interfaces,1985,15(3):106-115.
[36] E.CRosenthal,J.L.Zydiak,S.S.Chaudhry.Vendor selection with bundling[J].Decision Sciences,1995,26(1):35-48.
[37] W.C.Benton.Quantity discount decision under conditions of multiple items,multiple suppliers and resource limitation[J].International Journal of Production Research,1992,29(10):1953-1961.
[38] S.H Ghodsypour and C.O'Brien.The total cost of logistics in suppliier selection,under conditions of multiple sourcing,multiple criteria and capacity constraint[J].International journal of Production Economics,2001,73:15-27.
[39] R.Narasimhan,K.Stoynoff.Optimising aggregate procurement allocation decisions[J].Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management,1986,22(1):23-30.
[40] Pirkul,H.,and Aras,O.A..Capacitated multiple item ordering problem with quanitity discount[J].IIE Transactions,1985,17(3):206-211.
[41] C.A.Weber,J.Current.A multiobjective approach to vendor selection[J].European Journal of Operational Research,1993,68:173-184.
[42] F.P.Buffa,W.M.Jackson.A goal programming model for purchase planning[J].Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management,1983,19(3):27-34.
[43] S.H Ghodsypour and C.O'Brien.A decision support system for supplier selection using an integrated analytic hierarchy process and linear programming[J].International journal of Production Economics,1998,56-57:199-212.
[44] D.Sharma,W.C.Benton,R.Srivastava.Competitive strategy and purchasing decision[C].Proceeding of the 1989 Annual Conference of the Decision Science Institute,1989,1088-1090.
[45] Khoo,L.P.,Tor,S.B.,Lee,S.S.G..The potential of intelligent software agents in the World Wide Web in the automated part procurement[J].International Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management,1998,34(1):46-52.
[46] Cook,R.L..Case-based reasoning systems in purchasing:applications and development[J].International Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management,1997,33(1):32-39.
[47] Albino,V.,Garavelli,A.C..A neural network application to subcontractor rating in construction forms[J].International Journal of Project Management,1998,16(1):9-14.
[48] Vokurka,R.J,Choobineh,J.,Vadi,L..A prototype expert system for the evaluation and selection of potential suppliers[J].International Journal of Operations and Production Management,1996,16(12):106-127.
[49] Isao Shiromaru.A fuzzy ssatisficing method for electric power plant coal purchase using genetic algorithms[J].Operational Research,2000,126:218-230.
[50] Ronen,B.,Trietsch,D..A decision support system for purchasing management of large projects[J].Operation Research,1998,36(6):882-890.
[51] Weber,C.A.,Desai,A..Determination of paths to vendor market efficiency using parallel co-ordinates representation:a negotiation tool for buyers[J].European Journal of Operational Research,1996,90:142-155.
[52] Weber,C.A.,Current,J.R.,Desai,A..Non-cooperative negotiation strategies for vendor selection[J].European Journal of Operational Research,1998,108:208-223.
[53] Schonberger,R.J.,and Gilbert J.P..Just-in-time purchasing:a challenge for U.S.industry[J].California Management Review,1983,26(1):54-68.
[54] Schonberger R.J..Some observations on the advantages and implementation issues of just-in-time production systems[J].Journal of Operations Management,1982,3:1-11.
[55] Hahn,C.K.,pinto P.A.,and Bragg,D.J..just-in-time production and purchasing[J].International Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management,Fall 1983,2-10.
[56] W.C.Benton,Hojung Shin.Manufacturing planning and control:the evolution of MRP and JIT integration[J].Operational Research,1998,110:411-440.
[57] Rosemary R.Fullerton,Cheryl S.McWatters.The production performance benefits from JIT implemention[J].Journal of Operations Management,2000,19:81-96.
[58] Richard E.White,Victor Prybutok.The relationship between JIT practices and type of production system[J].Omega,2001,29:113-124.
[59] R.N.Roy,K.K.Guin.A proposed model of JIT purchasing in a integrated steel plant[J].Int.J.Production Economics,1999,59:179-187.
[60] Zeger Degraeve,Filip Roodhooft.Improving the efficiency the purchasing process using total cost of ownership information:The case of heating electrodes at Cockerill Sambre S.A.[J].European Journal of Operational Research,1999,112:42-53.
[61] Yunzeng Wang.The optimality of myopic stocking policies for systems with decreasing purchasing prices[J].European Journal of Operational Research,2001,133:153-159.
[62] Yan Dong,Craig R.Carter,and Martin E.Dresner.JIT purchasing and performance:an exploratory analysis of buyer and supplier perspectives[J].Journal of Operations Management,2001,19(4):471-483.
[63] Arnt Buvik,Halskau.Relationship duration and buyer influence in just-in-time relationships[J].European Journal of Purchasing & Supply Management,2001,7(2):111-119.
[64] Farzaneh Fazel,Klaus P.Fischer,Erika W.Gilbert.JIT purchasing vs.EOQ with a price discount:An analytical comparison of inventory costs[J].Int.J.Production Economics,1998,54:101-109.
[65] Marc.J.Schniederjans,Qing Cao.A note on JIT purchasing vs.EOQ with a price discount:An expansion of inventory costs[J].Int.J.Production E conomics,2000,65:289-294.
[66] J.D.Hong,J.C.Hayya.Just-in-time purchasing:Single or multiple sourcing?[J].International Journal of Production Economics,1992,27:175-181.
[67] Birsen Karpak,Erdogan Kumcu,Rammohan R.Kasuganti.Purchasing materials in the supply chain:managing a multi-objective task[J].European Journal of Puchasing & Supply Management,2001,(7):209-216.
[68] R.V.Rammasesh,Recasting the traditional inventory model to implement just in time purchasing[J].Prod,Inv.Mgmt.J,1990,31(1):71-75.
[69] Christian Hofman,Supplier's pricing policy in a Just in time environment[J].Computer & Operations Research,2000,27:1357-1373.
[70] Isao Shiromaru.A fuzzy satisfying method for electric power plant coal purchase using genetic algorithms[J].Operational Research,2000,126:218-230.
[71] Srinivas Talluri,R.C.Baker.A multi-phase mathematical programming approach for effective supply chain design[J].European Journal of Operational Research,2002,141:544-558.
[72] Bowon Kim.Coordinating an innovation in supply chain management[J].European Journal of Operational Research,2000,123:568-58.
[73] Thompson,K.,Vendor profile analysis,Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management,1990,26(1):11-18.
[74] Grando,A.,Sianesi,A..Supply management:a vendor rating assessment,CEMS Business Review,1996,(1):199-212.
[75] Willis,T.H.,Huston,C.R.,Pohlkamp,F..Evaluation measures of just-in-time supplier performance[J].Production and Inventory Management Journal,2nd quarter,1993,1-5.
[76] Li,C.C.,Y.P.,Hung,J.S..A new measure for supplier performance evaluation[J].IIE Transactions on Operations Engineering,1997,29:753-758.
[77] Min,H.International supplier selection:a multi-attribute utility approach,International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management,1994,24(5):24-33.
[78] Petroni,A.,Braglia,M..Vendor selection using principle component analysis[J].The Journal of Supply Chain Management:A Global Review of Purchasing and Supply,2000,36(2):63-69.
[79] Das,C.,Tyagi,R..Wholesaler:a decision support system for wholesale procurement and distribution[J].International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management,1994,24(10):4-12.
[80] J.Current,C.Weber.Application of facility location modeling constructs to vendor selection[J].European Journal of Operational Research,1994,76(3):387-392.
[81] Karpak,B.,Kumcu,E.,Kasuganti,R..An application of visual interactive goal programming:a case in vendor selection decisions[J].Journal of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis1999,8:33-41.
[82] Akinc,U..Selection a set of vendors in a manufacturing environment[J].Journal of Operations Management,1993,11:107-122.
[83] Sadrian,A.A.,Yoon,Y.S..A procurement decision support system in business volume discount environment[J].Operations Research,1994,42(1):14-23.
[84] De Toni,A.Nassimbeni,G.,Just in time purchasing:an empirical study of operational practices,supplier development and performance[J].Omega,2000,28:631-651.
[85] Javier Gonzalez-Benito,Isabel Suarez-Gonzalez,Martin Spring.Complementarities between JIT purchasing practices:An economic analysis based on transaction costs[J].Int. J.Production Economics,2000,67:279-293.