考虑评标专家后悔与失望行为的多属性逆向拍卖

doi:10.16381/j.cnki.issn1003-207x.2022.0129

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 针对不同知识背景、不同利益主体的评标专家对多属性指标认知程度的差异性以及定性指标的模糊性问题，提出了一种将后悔理论、失望理论与区间犹豫模糊和云模型相结合的多属性逆向拍卖决策方法。首先，定义群体决策一致性的区间犹豫模糊度，确定多属性指标权重，避免评标专家之间的对立情绪。其次，构建了考虑评标专家后悔与失望规避行为的云模型决策方法，并分析后悔规避系数与失望规避系数对中标结果的影响。最后，通过算例分析验证本文方法的可行性和有效性。本文的研究结果可为不同风险偏好下的招标企业提供中标决策参考。

关键词: 多属性逆向拍卖；群体决策；后悔理论；失望理论

Abstract: Aiming at the differences in the cognition of multi-attribute indicators by bid evaluation experts with different knowledge backgrounds and different stakeholders and the ambiguity of qualitative indicators, a multi-attribute reverse auction decision-making method combining regret theory, disappointment theory, interval hesitation fuzzy and cloud model is proposed. Firstly, the interval hesitation ambiguity of group decision-making consistency is defined, the weight of multi-attribute indicators is determined, and the antagonistic emotions among bid evaluation experts are avoided. Secondly, a cloud model decision-making method considering the regret and disappointment avoidance psychology of bid evaluation experts is constructed, and the influence of regret psychology and disappointment psychology on the winning bid is analyzed. Finally, the feasibility and effectiveness of the method in this paper are proved through the analysis of examples and comparison of methods. The research results of this paper can provide bidding companies with different risk appetites to provide bid-winning decision-making suggestions.

Key words: multi-attribute reverse auction; group decision-making; regret theory; disappointment theory

中图分类号:

F234

刘达, 王晟嫣, 张惠萍, 赵旭东. 考虑评标专家后悔与失望行为的多属性逆向拍卖[J]. 中国管理科学, 2023, 31(3): 196-206.

LIU Da, WANG Sheng-yan, ZHANG Hui-ping, ZHAO Xu-dong. Multi-Attribute Reverse Auction Considering the Regret and Disappointment Aversion of Bid Evaluation Experts[J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2023, 31(3): 196-206.

参考文献

［1］孙亚辉, 冯玉强. 多属性密封拍卖模型及最优投标策略［J］. 系统工程理论与实践, 2010,30(7):1185-1189.Sun Yahui, Feng Yuqiang. Multi-attribute sealed-bid auction model and optimal bidding strategies［J］. Systems Engineering-Theory & Practice, 2010,30(7):1185-1189.
［2］ Cui X, Lai V S, Lowry P B, et al. The effects of bidder factors on online bidding strategies: A motivation-opportunity-ability (MOA) model［J］. Decision Support Systems, 2020, DOI:10.1016/j.dss.2020.113397.
［3］钱小虎, 黄敏, 高太光, 等. 基于BOCR与Choquet积分的多属性逆向拍卖决策［J］. 工业工程, 2013,16(6):54-59.Qian Xiaohu, Huang Min, Gao Taiguang, et al. Multi-attribute decision making based on BOCR and Choquet integral in reverse auction［J］. Industrial Engineering Journal, 2013,16(6):54-59.
［4］钱小虎. 考虑决策者有限理性行为的逆向拍卖机制研究［D］. 沈阳：东北大学, 2016.Qian Xiaohu.Mechanism design considering the boundedly rational behavior of decision-makers in reverse auctions［D］. Northeastern University,2016.
［5］ Dotoli M, Epicoco N, Falagario M. Multi-Criteria decision making techniques for the management of public procurement tenders: A case study［J］. Applied Soft Computing, 2020, DOI:10.1016/j.asoc.2020.106064.
［6］ Cheaitou A, Larbi R, Al Housani B. Decision making framework for tender evaluation and contractor selection in public organizations with risk considerations［J］. Socio-Economic Planning Sciences, 2019, DOI10.1016/j.seps.2018.02.007.
［7］ Chen Zhensong, Zhang Xuan, Pedrycz W, et al. Bid evaluation in civil construction under uncertainty: a two-stage LSP-ELECTRE III-based approach［J］. Engineering Applications of Artificial Intelligence, 2020, DOI10.1016/j.engappai.2020.103835.
［8］曾宪科, 冯玉强, 杨睿. 基于价格歧视策略的多单元逆向多属性英式拍卖机制［J］. 运筹与管理, 2015,24(2):163-169.Zeng Xianke, Feng Yuqiang, Yang Rui. Muti-unit reverse multi-attribute English auction mechanism based on the strategy of price discrimination［J］. Operations Research and Management Science, 2015,24(2):163-169.
［9］杨锋, 何慕佳, 梁樑. 基于多属性逆向拍卖的节能服务公司选择研究［J］. 中国管理科学, 2015,23(5):98-106.Yang Feng, He Mujia, Liang Liang. Selecting energy service company based on multi-attribute reverse auction［J］. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2015,23(5):98-106.
［10］方炜, 戴晟, 杨步, 等. 基于多属性逆向拍卖的大型复杂工程项目承包商选择研究［J］. 工业技术经济, 2018,37(6):117-127.Fang Wei, Dai Sheng, Yang Bu, et al. Selecting large and complex engineering project contractor multi-attribute reverse auction［J］. Journal of Industrial Technological Economics, 2018,37(6):117-127.
［11］高广鑫. 考虑决策者心理行为的若干拍卖问题研究［D］. 沈阳：东北大学, 2016.Gao Guangxin. Research on several auction problems considering decision makers’ psychological behaviors［D］.Northeastern University,2016.
［12］高广鑫, 樊治平, 尤天慧, 等. 考虑全局投标者后悔心理行为的组合拍卖的投标均衡策略［J］. 运筹与管理, 2019,28(1):135-144.Gao Guangxin, Fan Zhiping, You Tianhui, et al. Equilibrium bidding strategy in combinatorial auctions considering the global bidder’s regret behaviors［J］. Operations Research and Management Science, 2019,28(1):135-144.
［13］ Engelbrecht-Wiggans R, Katok E. A direct test of risk aversion and regret in first price sealed-bid auctions［J］. Decision Analysis, 2009,6(2):75-86.
［14］ Engelbrecht-Wiggans R, Katok E. Regret and feedback information in first-price sealed-bid auctions［J］. Management Science, 2008,54(4):808-819.
［15］ Engelbrecht-Wiggans R, Katok E. Regret in auctions: theory and evidence［J］. Economic Theory, 2007,33(1):81-101.
［16］ Sonsino D. Disappointment aversion in Internet bidding-decisions［J］. Theory and Decision, 2008,64(2-3):363-393.
［17］ Qian Xiaohu, Fang Shucherng, Huang Min, et al. Reverse auctions with regret-anticipated bidders［J］. Annals of Operations Research, 2018,268(1-2):293-313.
［18］郭娅舒. 考虑投标者后悔心理行为的组合拍卖投标策略研究［D］. 沈阳：东北大学, 2015.Guo Yashu. Study on the bidding strategy of combinatorial auctions considering the bidders’regret［D］. Northeastern University,2016.
［19］ Zadeh L A. Fuzzy sets［J］. Information and Control, 1965,8(3):338-353.
［20］ Turksen I B. Interval valued fuzzy sets based on normal forms［J］. Fuzzy Sets and Systems, 1986,20(2):191-210.
［21］ Torra V, Narukawa Y. On Hesitant Fuzzy Sets and Decision［C］//The 18th IEEE International Conference on Fuzzy Systems, Jeju Island, Korea, 2009.
［22］ Chen Na, Xu Zeshui, Xia Meimei. Interval-valued hesitant preference relations and their applications to group decision making［J］. Knowledge-Based Systems, 2013,37:528-540.
［23］李德毅. 不确定性人工智能［M］. 北京: 国防工业出版社, 2005.Li Deyi.Artificial intelligence with uncertainty second edition［M］.National Defense Industry Press,2005.
［24］莫国莉, 张卫国, 刘芳, 等. 基于前景云的不确定语言多准则国际股指投资群决策［J］. 运筹与管理, 2019,28(2):126-138.Mo Guoli, Zhang Weiguo, Liu Fang, et al. Uncertain-language multi-criteria group decision making based on prospect-cloud model for stock indices investment in international wide［J］. Operations Research and Management Science, 2019,28(2):126-138.
［25］狄鹏, 倪子纯, 尹东亮. 基于云模型和证据理论的多属性决策优化算法［J］. 系统工程理论与实践, 2021,41(4):1061-1070.Di Peng, Ni Zichun, Yin Dongliang. A multi-attribute decision making optimization algorithm based on cloud model and evidence theory［J］. Systems Engineering-Theory & Practice, 2021,41(4):1061-1070.
［26］ Bell D E. Regret in Decision Making under Uncertainty［J］. Operations research, 1982,30(5):961-981.
［27］ Bell D E. Disappointment in Decision Making under Uncertainty［J］. Operations Research, 1985,33(1):31-33.
［28］ Zhang Xiaolu, Xu Zeshui. Hesitant fuzzy QUALIFLEX approach with a signed distance-based comparison method for multiple criteria decision analysis［J］. Expert Systems with Applications, 2015,42(2):873-884.
［29］姚远. 基于后悔理论及云模型的多属性群决策方法［J］. 数学的实践与认识, 2020,50(17):22-34.Yao Yuan. Multi-attribute group decision making method based on regret theory and cloud model［J］. Mathematics in Practice and Theory, 2020,50(17):22-34.
［30］李娜, 高雷阜, 王磊. 基于Pythagorean模糊熵的风险型决策方法——考虑后悔与失望规避［J］. 运筹与管理, 2020,29(6):130-138.Li Na, Gao Leifu, Wang Lei. Risky multiple attribute decision making based on Pythagorean fuzzy entropy: With regret aversion and disappointment aversion［J］. Operations Research and Management Science, 2020,29(6):130-138.
［31］ Laciana C E, Weber E U. Correcting expected utility for comparisons between alternative outcomes: A unified parameterization of regret and disappointment［J］. Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 2008,36(1):1-17.
［32］ Tversky A, Kahneman D. Advances in Prospect Theory: Cumulative Representation of Uncertainty［J］. Journal of Risk & Uncertainty, 1992,5(4):493-519.
［33］杨恶恶, 王坚强, 马超群, 等. 基于云发生算法的犹豫语言多准则决策方法［J］. 控制与决策, 2015,30(2):371-374.Yang Wue, Wang Jianqiang, Ma Chaoqun, et al. Hesitant linguistic multiple criteria decision making method based on cloud generating algorithm［J］. Control and Decision, 2015,30(2):371-374.
［34］刘旭旺, 汪定伟. 博弈论视角的多属性逆向拍卖评标行为研究［J］. 运筹学学报, 2012,16(4):11-20.Liu Xuwang, Wang Dingwei. Study of bid evaluation behaviors for multi-attribute reverse auction based on game theory［J］. Operations Research Transactions, 2012,16(4):11-20.
［35］谢安石, 李一军. 基于模糊粗糙集的多属性网上拍卖决策［J］. 系统工程理论方法应用, 2005(2):182-184.Xie Anshi, Li Yijun. Multi-attribute decision making based on fuzzy rough set in E-auction［J］. Journal of Systems & Management, 2005(2):182-184.
［36］朱佳翔, 蔡建飞, 林徐勋. 基于CI-TOPSIS的梯形直觉模糊多准则群决策分类方法［J］. 中国管理科学, 2018,26(9):148-157.Zhu Jiaxiang, Cai Jianfei, Lin Xuxun. Multiple criteria sorting method in the group decision making context with trapezoidal intuitionistic fuzzy values based on CI-TOPSIS［J］. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2018,26(9):148-157.
［37］ Perez-Dominguez L, Alberto Rodriguez-Picon L, Alvarado-Iniesta A, et al. MOORA under Pythagorean fuzzy set for multiple criteria decision making［J］. Complexity, 2018, DOI:10.1155/2018/2602376.
［38］ Chen Tingyu. Remoteness index-based Pythagorean fuzzy VIKOR methods with a generalized distance measure for multiple criteria decision analysis［J］. Information Fusion, 2018,41:129-150.

[1]	朱宝琳, 崔世旭, 戢守峰, 邱若臻. 产需不确定下基于零售商风险规避的三级供应链组合契约模型[J]. 中国管理科学, 2018, 26(11): 114-123.
[2]	蒋艳辉, 马超群, 熊希希. 创业板上市公司文本惯性披露、信息相似度与资产定价——基于Fama-French改进模型的经验分析[J]. 中国管理科学, 2014, 22(8): 56-63.
[3]	蒋艳霞, 徐程兴. 基于集成支持向量机的企业财务业绩分类模型研究[J]. 中国管理科学, 2009, 17(2): 42-51.
[4]	陈晓红, 王小丁, 曾江洪. 中小企业债权治理评价与成长性研究——来自中国中小上市公司的经验证据[J]. 中国管理科学, 2008, 16(1): 163-171.