主管:中国科学院
主办:中国优选法统筹法与经济数学研究会
   中国科学院科技战略咨询研究院

中国管理科学 ›› 2020, Vol. 28 ›› Issue (4): 1-13.doi: 10.16381/j.cnki.issn1003-207x.2020.04.001

• 论文 •    下一篇

股指期货交易加剧了中国股票市场波动性吗?——基于投资者结构的理论和实证研究

陈其安, 张慧, 陈抒妤   

  1. 重庆大学经济与工商管理学院, 重庆 400030
  • 收稿日期:2018-06-04 修回日期:2019-04-12 出版日期:2020-04-20 发布日期:2020-04-30
  • 通讯作者: 陈其安(1968-),男(汉族),重庆綦江人,重庆大学经济与工商管理学院,教授,博士,博士生导师,研究方向:金融市场、企业理论和行为经济学,E-mail:chenqi_an33@163.com. E-mail:chenqi_an33@163.com
  • 基金资助:
    国家社会科学基金重点资助项目(19AGL013);重庆市研究生科研创新项目(CYS17029)

Does Stock Index Futures Trading Increase the Stock Market Volatility in China?——Theoretical and Empirical Research Based on Investor Structure

CHEN Qi-an, ZHANG Hui, CHEN Shu-yu   

  1. School of Economics and Business Administration, Chongqing University, Chongqing 400044, China
  • Received:2018-06-04 Revised:2019-04-12 Online:2020-04-20 Published:2020-04-30

摘要: 股指期货交易的推出将改变股票市场投资者结构和投资者交易行为,进而对股票市场波动性产生影响。本文首先在假设股票市场存在股指期货交易的条件下,构建理论模型揭示投资者结构和股指期货交易对股票市场波动性的影响机理,并据此对中国股票市场在沪深300股指期货推出后的波动性变化进行理论预测;然后以2007-2016年期间的沪深300指数和投资者结构数据为样本,运用GARCH类模型对理论模型预测结果进行实证检验。研究发现,在股票市场存在股指期货交易的条件下,机构投资者比例和一般机构投资者比例对股票市场波动性的影响随机构投资者与个人投资者所占市场份额的比例关系不同而呈现出不同的特征;套利交易者比例增加、投机交易者比例减少都将降低股票市场波动性;沪深300股指期货推出显著降低了中国股票市场波动性,机构投资者比例增加将强化沪深300股指期货交易对中国股票市场波动性的减弱效应;中国证券监管部门可以通过鼓励股指期货产品开发和完善股指期货交易制度强化中国股票市场稳定性。

关键词: 投资者结构, 股指期货, 中国股票市场, 波动性

Abstract: The introduction of stock index futures trading may prompt changes of investor structure and their trading behaviors, thus having an effect on stock market volatility. Since the official launch of the CSI 300 stock index futures trading on April 16, 2010, the surge and crash phenomenon in China's stock market has not been significantly improved intuitively and there has been controversy over whether stock index futures trading will increase or reduce the volatility of the stock market. Therefore, the study on the influence of stock index futures trading and investor structure on stock market volatility has important theoretical and practical significance for clarifying the role of stock index futures trading on the stability of China's stock market, optimizing the investor structure, improving the trading system of the stock index futures and ensuring Chinese stock market to develop healthily and steadily. First, a mathematical model is established to theoretically study the effect mechanisms of the stock index futures trading and investor structure on the stock market volatility based on the behavioral characteristics of various investors in stock and future markets. The following theoretical research results are obtained. In the presence of stock index futures trading in stock market, the stock market price volatility will decrease with the increase of the proportion of arbitragers, and increase with the increase in the proportion of speculative traders and in their speculation. When institutional investors hold more market share than individual investors, the stock market volatility would decrease with the increase in the institutional investors' market share. When the market share of institutional investors is more than individual investors and speculators are more speculative, or the market shares of institutional investors is more than individual investors but does not exceed a certain threshold and speculators are less speculative, the stock market price volatility is negatively correlated with the proportion of general institutional investors.When the market share of institutional investors is more than individual investors and exceeds a certain threshold and speculators are less speculative, stock market price volatility is positively correlated with the proportion of general institutional investors.When institutional investors have less than 50% market share, the impact of the proportion of institutional investors and general institutional investors on stock market volatility depends on the unanticipated changes in the macro economy, the capacity level of investor, the proportion of general institutional investors and arbitrager, the margin ratio of spot and futures trading, the speculative strength of speculator and many other factors, and there are many uncertainties.Then the volatility changes of the China's stock market before and after the launch of the CSI 300 stock index futures are theoretically forecasted based on the theoretical model results and the changes in the structure of investors in the Chinese stock market. And taking the CSI 300 index and investor structure data from January 4, 2007 to April 5, 2016 as samples, the GARCH model is used to empirically test the theoretical prediction results. The empirical research results show that after the launch of the CSI 300 stock index futures trading, the volatility of the Chinese stock market would be negatively related to the market share of institutional investors, and the launch of CSI 300 stock index futures significantly reduced the volatility of the China's stock market. The increase in the proportion of institutional investors will strengthen the weakening effect of CSI 300 stock index futures trading on the volatility of China's stock market. These empirical results prove the validity of the theoretical model and its prediction results empirically.The research results of this paper provide theoretical and empirical evidence for the inhibitory effect of stock index futures trading on the Chinese stock market volatility based on the investor structure and investors' trading behavior characteristics, and clearly answer the question of whether the volatility of China's stock market has increased or decreased after the introduction of stock index futures, and negates some investors' intuitive feeling and idea that stock index futures trading will increase the volatility of China's stock market, and provide theoretical and practical guidance for China's development and improvement of the stock index futures market. China's securities regulators should vigorously develop stock index futures products and increase financial risk management tools, strengthen the cultivation of institutional investors from both quantitative and qualitative aspects and improve the ability of institutional investors to use stock index futures trading for hedging and risk management, and improve the stock index futures trading system and curb speculative traders' speculative behavior to strengthen the role of stock index futures trading in stabilizing the stock market.

Key words: investor structure, stock index future, Chinese stock market, volatility

中图分类号: