供应链ESG：研究框架、挑战与未来研究方向

doi:10.16381/j.cnki.issn1003-207x.2024.1775

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

随着全球经济、社会和环境挑战的加剧，ESG逐渐成为提升企业声誉与供应链竞争力的关键。但当前学术界对ESG的研究多集中于单个企业或单一维度，而关于供应链层面ESG的系统性研究相对较少。鉴于此，本研究首先梳理了现有企业层面和供应链层面ESG的相关研究，其次结合不同组织和机构对供应链ESG的理解界定了供应链ESG的概念内涵，然后围绕供应链成员行为、监管与合规、信息披露、驱动机制以及风险管理五个方面内容构建了供应链ESG的研究框架。在此基础上，进一步分析了供应链ESG所面临的挑战。最后，从标准化与政策驱动、竞合关系以及技术驱动与创新等视角提供了供应链ESG的未来研究方向。

关键词: 供应链ESG, ESG信息披露, ESG合规, ESG挑战, ESG实践

Abstract:

With the intensification of global economic， social and environmental challenges， ESG has gradually become the key to enhancing corporate reputation and supply chain competitiveness. However， the current academic research on ESG mostly focuses on single-point enterprises， and there are relatively few systematic studies on ESG at the supply chain level. In view of this， the existing research on ESG is reviewed at the enterprise level and the supply chain level. Secondly， the concept of supply chain ESG is defined based on the understanding of supply chain ESG by different organizations and institutions. Then， the research framework of supply chain ESG is constructed around five aspects： supply chain member behavior， supervision and compliance， information disclosure， driving mechanism and risk management. After that， the challenges faced by supply chain ESG are analyzed. Finally， it provides the future research direction of supply chain ESG from the perspectives of standardization and policy drive， competition and cooperation relationship， technology drive and innovation.

Key words: supply chain ESG, ESG information disclosure, ESG compliance, ESG challenge, ESG practice

中图分类号:

F272

刘家国,赵亚涛,李健, 等. 供应链ESG：研究框架、挑战与未来研究方向[J]. 中国管理科学, 2025, 33(11): 185-196.

Jiaguo Liu,Yatao Zhao,Jian Li, et al. Supply Chain ESG: Research Framework, Challenges and Future Research Directions[J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2025, 33(11): 185-196.

图/表 1

参考文献 56

[1]	马茹，罗晖，王宏伟，等. 中国区域经济高质量发展评价指标体系及测度研究［J］. 中国软科学， 2019（7）： 60-67.
	Ma R， Luo H， Wang H W， et al. Study of evaluating high-quality economic development in Chinese regions［J］. China Soft Science， 2019（7）： 60-67.
[2]	Chen Q， Duan Y. Impact of information disclosure on global supply chain greenwashing： Is more information transparency always better？［J］. Transportation Research Part E： Logistics and Transportation Review， 2023， 178： 103288.
[3]	Lee M T， Raschke R L. Stakeholder legitimacy in firm greening and financial performance： What about greenwashing temptations？［J］. Journal of Business Research， 2023， 155： 113393.
[4]	DasGupta R. Financial performance shortfall， ESG controversies， and ESG performance： Evidence from firms around the world［J］. Finance Research Letters， 2022， 46： 102487.
[5]	李宗泽，李志斌. 企业ESG信息披露同群效应研究［J］. 南开管理评论， 2023， 26（5）： 126-138.
	Li Z Z， Li Z B. Research on peer effect of enterprise ESG information disclosure［J］. Nankai Business Review， 2023， 26（5）： 126-138.
[6]	Zhang K， Liu X， Wang J. Exploring the relationship between corporate ESG information disclosure and audit fees： Evidence from non-financial A-share listed companies in China［J］. Frontiers in Environmental Science， 2023， 11： 1196728.
[7]	Reber B， Gold A， Gold S. ESG disclosure and idiosyncratic risk in initial public offerings［J］. Journal of Business Ethics， 2022， 179（3）： 867-886.
[8]	战飞扬，董纪昌，方锦程，等. 合规政策对上市公司ESG绩效的影响：基于央企合规管理指引的准自然实验［J］.系统工程理论与实践，2025，45（5）： 1485-1496.
	Zhan F Y， Dong J C， Fang J C， et al. Impact of compliance guidelines on ESG rating performance of listed enterprises： Based on the quasi-natural experiment of guidelines on compliance management of central enterprises［J］. Systems Engineering-Theory & Practice， 2025， 45（5）： 1485-1496.
[9]	Shakil M H. Environmental， social and governance performance and financial risk： Moderating role of ESG controversies and board gender diversity［J］. Resources Policy， 2021， 72： 102144.
[10]	Shen B， Cao Y， Minner S. Paying living wages in supply chains： The effects of uncertainties， coordination， and competition［J］. Production and Operations Management， 2025， 34（5）： 1076-1093.
[11]	Gualandris J， Longoni A， Luzzini D， et al. The association between supply chain structure and transparency： A large-scale empirical study［J］. Journal of Operations Management， 2021， 67（7）： 803-827.
[12]	Li J， Lian G， Xu A. How do ESG affect the spillover of green innovation among peer firms？ Mechanism discussion and performance study［J］. Journal of Business Research， 2023， 158： 113648.
[13]	俞莹，吴和成，易荣华. 企业ESG表现与价值创造——基于内部发展和外部压力的视角［J］. 中国管理科学， 2025， 33（3）： 107-117.
	Yu Y， Wu H C， Yi R H. Corporate ESG performance and value creation： Based on the perspective of internal development and external pressure［J］. Chinese Journal of Management Science， 2025， 33（3）： 107-117.
[14]	粟金霞，周利国. 供应链视角下企业ESG表现对客户违约风险的影响研究［J］. 管理学报， 2024， 21（9）： 1392-1400.
	Su J X， Zhou L G. The impact of ESG performance on customer default risk from the perspective of supply chain［J］. Chinese Journal of Management， 2024， 21（9）： 1392-1400.
[15]	Dai T， Tang C. Frontiers in service science： integrating ESG measures and supply chain management： research opportunities in the postpandemic era［J］. Service Science， 2022， 14（1）： 1-12.
[16]	Niu B， Dai Z， Chen L. Information leakage in a cross-border logistics supply chain considering demand uncertainty and signal inference［J］. Annals of Operations Research， 2022， 309（2）： 785-816.
[17]	Arvidsson S， Dumay J. Corporate ESG reporting quantity， quality and performance： Where to now for environmental policy and practice？［J］. Business Strategy and the Environment， 2022， 31（3）： 1091-1110.
[18]	Alison Mackey T B M. Corporate social responsibility and firm performance： Investor preferences and corporate strategies［J］. The Academy of Management Review， 2007， 32（3）： 817-835.
[19]	Yang L， Guo Z. Evolution of CSR Concept in the West and China［J］. International Review of Management and Business Research， 2014， 3（2）： 819.
[20]	Kaplan R S， David P. Norton， the balanced scorecard： translating strategy into action［J］. Harvard Business Review Press， 1996， 1.
[21]	Truant E， Borlatto E， Crocco E， et al. Environmental， social and governance issues in supply chains. A systematic review for strategic performance［J］. Journal of Cleaner Production， 2024， 434： 140024.
[22]	Binder C R， Hinkel J， Bots P W G， et al. Comparison of frameworks for analyzing social-ecological systems［J］. Ecology and Society， 2013， 18（4）： art26.
[23]	蒋艺翅，姚树洁. ESG信息披露、外部关注与企业风险［J］. 系统管理学报， 2024， 33（1）： 214-229.
	Jiang Y C， Yao S J. ESG disclosure， external concerns， and firm risk［J］. Journal of Systems & Management， 2024， 33（1）： 214-229.
[24]	谭劲松，黄仁玉，张京心. ESG表现与企业风险-基于资源获取视角的解释［J］. 管理科学， 2022， 35（5）： 3-18.
	Tan J S， Huang R Y， Zhang J X. ESG performance and corporate risk： An explanation from a resource acquisition perspective［J］. Journal of Management Science， 2022， 35（5）： 3-18.
[25]	Shao L， Wu X， Zhang F. Sourcing competition under cost uncertainty and information asymmetry［J］. Production and Operations Management，2020，29（2）： 447-461.
[26]	王文宾，王智慧，杨斯奇，等. 制造商竞争下闭环供应链的押金返还制度研究［J］. 中国管理科学， 2021， 29（6）： 179-188.
	Wang W B， Wang Z H， Yang S Q， et al. Deposit-refund system of a closed-loop supply chain under competition between manufacturers［J］. Chinese Journal of Management Science， 2021， 29（6）： 179-188.
[27]	Luo Z， Chen X， Wang X. The role of co-opetition in low carbon manufacturing［J］. European Journal of Operational Research， 2016， 253（2）： 392-403.
[28]	Li Y， Huang L， Tong Y. Cooperation with competitor or not？ The strategic choice of a focal firm’s green innovation strategy［J］. Computers & Industrial Engineering， 2021， 157： 107301.
[29]	Pizzetti M， Gatti L， Seele P. Firms talk， suppliers walk： Analyzing the locus of greenwashing in the blame game and introducing ‘vicarious greenwashing’［J］. Journal of Business Ethics， 2021， 170（1）： 21-38.
[30]	Jahdi K S， Acikdilli G. Marketing communications and corporate social responsibility （CSR）： Marriage of convenience or shotgun wedding？［J］. Journal of Business Ethics， 2009， 88（1）： 103-113.
[31]	Flammer C. Corporate social responsibility and shareholder reaction： The environmental awareness of investors［J］. Academy of Management Journal， 2013， 56（3）： 758-781.
[32]	Zhang M， Shen Q， Zhao Z， et al. Commitment or rent-seeking？ Government incentive policies for ESG reporting in sustainable e-commerce logistics［J］. International Journal of Production Economics， 2024， 268： 109134.
[33]	He F， Qin S， Liu Y， et al. CSR and idiosyncratic risk： Evidence from ESG information disclosure［J］. Finance Research Letters， 2022， 49： 102936.
[34]	郑丽，房康，王媛媛. 双重绩效反馈不一致与企业ESG信息披露质量的关系研究［J］. 研究与发展管理， 2024， 36（1）： 53-65.
	Zheng L， Fang K， Wang Y Y. Impact of dual performance feedback inconsistency on the quality of corporate ESG information disclosure［J］. R&D Management， 2024， 36（1）： 53-65.
[35]	Chen L， Lee H L. Sourcing under supplier responsibility risk： The effects of certification， audit， and contingency payment［J］. Management Science， 2017， 63（9）： 2795-2812.
[36]	Wu Y， Zhang K， Xie J. Bad greenwashing， good greenwashing： Corporate social responsibility and information transparency［J］. Management Science， 2020， 66（7）： 3095-3112.
[37]	冉茂盛，张世广，陈雪娥. 基于信号博弈的卖方欺诈行为分析［J］.中国管理科学，2021， 29（8）： 195-205.
	Ran M S， Zhang S G， Chen X E. Analysis of vendor fraud based on signal game［J］. Chinese Journal of Management Science， 2021， 29（8）： 195-205.
[38]	Sardanelli D， Bittucci L， Mirone F， et al. An integrative framework for supply chain rating： From financial-based to ESG-based rating models［J/OL］. Total Quality Management & Business Excellence，2022. .
[39]	Gunawan J， Gunawan I， Liu Y C. Environmental， social， and governance （ESG） performance evaluation to reduce potential greenwashing based on sustainable fitch index［J］. International Journal of Entrepreneurship and Sustainability Studies， 2023， 3（2）： 29-39.
[40]	Chowdhury M A F， Abdullah M， Azad M A K， et al. Environmental， social and governance （ESG） rating prediction using machine learning approaches［J/OL］. Annals of Operations Research， 2023. .
[41]	Zhou Y， Yuen K F. A Bayesian network model for container shipping companies’ organisational sustainability risk management［J］. Transportation Research Part D： Transport and Environment， 2024， 126： 103999.
[42]	Arvidsson S， Dumay J. Corporate ESG reporting quantity， quality and performance： Where to now for environmental policy and practice？［J］. Business Strategy and the Environment， 2022， 31（3）： 1091-1110.
[43]	Ghaemi Asl M， Adekoya O B， Rashidi M M. Quantiles dependence and dynamic connectedness between distributed ledger technology andsectoral stocks： Enhancing the supply chain and investment decisions with digital platforms［J］. Annals of Operations Research， 2023， 327（1）： 435-464.
[44]	Bozarth C C， Warsing D P， Flynn B B， et al. The impact of supply chain complexity on manufacturing plant performance［J］. Journal of operations management， 2009， 27（1）： 78-93.
[45]	Tsao Y C， Lee P L， Chen C H， et al. Sustainable newsvendor models under trade credit［J］. Journal of Cleaner Production， 2017， 141： 1478-1491.
[46]	刘家国，赵慧达，李健. 基于绿色投资效率的港航供应链投资策略研究［J］. 中国管理科学， 2021， 29（11）： 33-44.
	Liu J G， Zhao H D， Li J. Research on investment strategy of maritime supply chain based on green investment efficiency［J］. Chinese Journal of Management Science， 2021， 29（11）： 33-44.
[47]	Lai Z， Lou G， Zhang T， et al. Financing and coordination strategies for a manufacturer with limited operating and green innovation capital： Bank credit financing versus supplier green investment［J］. Annals of Operations Research， 2023， 331（1）： 85-119.
[48]	Haenlein M， Kaplan A. A brief history of artificial intelligence： On the past， present， and future of artificial intelligence［J］. California Management Review， 2019， 61（4）： 5-14.
[49]	Mansouri S， Momtaz P P. Financing sustainable entrepreneurship： ESG measurement， valuation， and performance［J］. Journal of Business Venturing， 2022， 37（6）： 106258.
[50]	Wu Z， Yang L， Fei Y， et al. Regularization methods for sparse ESG-valued multi-period portfolio optimization with return prediction using machine learning［J］. Expert Systems with Applications， 2023， 232： 120850.
[51]	Zhang D. The pathway to curb greenwashing in sustainable growth： The role of artificial intelligence［J］. Energy Economics， 2024， 133： 107562.
[52]	Chen S， Song Y， Gao P. Environmental， social， and governance （ESG） performance and financial outcomes： Analyzing the impact of ESG on financial performance［J］. Journal of Environmental Management， 2023， 345： 118829.
[53]	Cho W， Lee J， Park J. Higher highs and lower lows： Investor valuation of ESG and financial performance［J］. Applied Economics Letters， 2024， 31（16）： 1482-1487.
[54]	Weston P， Nnadi M. Evaluation of strategic and financial variables of corporate sustainability and ESG policies on corporate finance performance［J］. Journal of Sustainable Finance & Investment， 2023， 13（2）： 1058-1074.
[55]	Lee M T， Raschke R L， Krishen A S. Signaling green！ firm ESG signals in an interconnected environment that promote brand valuation［J］. Journal of Business Research， 2022， 138： 1-11.
[56]	Haber S， Stornetta W S. How to time-stamp a digital document［J］. Journal of Cryptology， 1991， 3（2）： 99-111.