废旧产品的回收再制造过程往往在回收质量、再制造成本、再制造产出率、再制造产品需求等方面存在不确定性因素,极大地增加了再制造生产管理决策的复杂性。本文在一个回收再制造系统中研究了存在多种回收质量等级时的两阶段回收—再制造联合优化决策问题,并扩展到需求与价格相关和再制造产出率随机两种情形。在最大化再制造商期望利润的决策目标下,基于每种回收质量等级的单位回收和再制造成本构造出再制造系统的有效生产前沿面,给出了不同决策情形下再制造商的最优回收数量、销售定价的解析解,并且分析了一些主要的参数对再制造商最优决策的影响。本文的研究结果表明:(1)含有多种回收质量等级的再制造系统中存在一个下凸的有效生产前沿面,不在该前沿面上的任何质量等级的回收产品都将不会被用于再制造;(2)在同等的政府补贴额度下,回收补贴方式对再制造商决策的影响程度大于再制造补贴方式;(3)当再制造品的市场需求与价格相关时,最优销售价格至少大于第一种被使用的回收质量等级的边际回收和再制造成本;(4)任意两种回收质量等级之间存在着替代或互补效应,由其成本差异决定,并且这种效应随着需求不确定性的增大而增大;(5)再制造产出率的不确定性和再制造品需求的不确定性之间存在"对冲"效应,这种效应随着再制造产出率不确定性的降低而减弱。本文的研究可为不确定性环境下再制造企业的回收、生产管理决策提供有益的管理启示。
There are many uncertainty factors in core acquisition and remanufacturing such as the quality and remanufacturing cost of cores, yield of the remanufacturing process, market demand for the remanufactured products and so on.As a result, the decision-making in production and core acquisition in a remanufacturing system becomes very challenging. A two-stage dynamic model is employed to study the optimal acquisition and production decisions of a remanufacturing system with multiple types of cores under demand uncertainty. This model is then extended to cases with a price-sensitive demand and/or random remanufacturing yield. With the objective of maximizing the expected profit of the remanufacturer, an efficient production frontier with respect to the unit acquisition and remanufacturing cost of each type of cores is first characterized. Based on the backward induction method, the optimal decisions of core acquisition and production are then derived for each case.Numerical experiments are conducted to investigate the impacts of government subsidy, demand uncertainty, price sensitivity of demandand remanufacturing yield variation on the remanufacturer's optimal acquisition, production and pricing decisions. Our theoretical and numerical results show that:(1) there exists a convex and downward sloping efficient production frontier in the remanufacturing system so that any type of cores that is not lying on the frontier will never be used; (2) for the same amount of subsidies, core acquisition subsidy is more efficient than remanufacturing subsidy; (3) for the price-sensitive demand, the optimal price is larger than the sum of the unit acquisition and remanufacturing cost of the first used type of cores; (4) there exists a substitution or complementary effect between any two types of cores, depending on the differences in their unit acquisition and remanufacturing cost; and(5) there exists an hedging effect between demand uncertainty and remanufacturing yield variation, which is decreasing in the degree of demand uncertainty. Our research provides useful managerial insights for remanufacturing firms to make core acquisition and production decisions under uncertain environments.
[1] 徐滨士,朱胜,史佩京. 绿色再制造技术的创新发展[J]. 焊接技术,2016,45(5):11-14.
[2] Treat A,Honnold V,Wise J,et al. Remanufactured goods:An overview of the U.S. and global industries, markets and trade[R]. Working paper, United States International Trade Commission,2012.
[3] Guide Jr. V D R,Teunter R H,Van Wassenhove L N. Matching demand and supply to maximize profits from remanufacturing[J]. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management,2003,5(4):303-316.
[4] Galbreth M R, Blackburn J D. Optimal acquisition and sorting policies for remanufacturing[J]. Production and Operations Management,2006,15(3):384-392.
[5] 杨爱峰,季园园,胡小建,等. 质量不确定的回收品采购量及再制造排序策略[J]. 合肥工业大学学报,2014,37(4):473-477.
[6] 王巍. 闭环供应链分级定价回收策略研究[J]. 统计与决策,2010,(5):174-176.
[7] 温海骏,刘明周,刘长义,等. 多品种汽车发动机两阶段模糊再制造生产计划[J]. 计算机集成制造系统,2016,22(2):529-537.
[8] Zhou S X,Tao Zhijie,Chao Xiuli. Optimal control of inventory systems with multiple types of remanufacturable products[J]. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management,2011,13(1):20-34.
[9] Tao Zhijie,Zhou S X,Tang C S. Managing a remanufacturing system with random yield:Properties, observations, and heuristics[J]. Production and Operations Management,2012,21(5):797-813.
[10] 吴鹏,陈剑. 考虑回收数量不确定性的生产决策优化[J]. 系统工程学报,2008,23(6):644-649.
[11] 李响,李勇建,蔡小强. 随机产率和随机需求下的再制造系统的回收定价决策[J]. 系统工程理论与实践,2009,29(8):19-27.
[12] Zhou S X,Yu Yikun. Optimal product acquisition, pricing, and inventory management for systems with remanufacturing[J]. Operations Research,2011,59(2):514-521.
[13] 王文宾,达庆利. 奖惩机制下具竞争制造商的废旧产品回收决策模型[J]. 中国管理科学,2013,21(5):50-56.
[14] 王文宾,邓雯雯. 逆向供应链的政府奖惩机制与税收-补贴机制比较研究[J]. 中国管理科学,2016,24(4):102-110.
[15] 刘慧慧,黄涛,雷明. 废旧电器电子产品双渠道回收模型及政府补贴作用研究[J]. 中国管理科学,2013,21(2):123-131.
[16] 聂佳佳. 需求信息预测对制造商回收再制造策略的价值[J]. 管理科学学报,2014,17(1):35-47.
[17] 吴鹏. 回收再制造供应链协调问题研究[J]. 华南理工大学学报(社会科学版),2013,15(2):35-40.
[18] 孙浩,达庆利.基于不同权力结构的废旧产品回收再制造决策分析[J]. 中国管理科学,2009,17(5):104-112.
[19] 史成东,闫秀霞,闫厚强,等. Loss-averse测度下考虑政府补贴的双第三方回收再制造闭环供应链[J]. 中国管理科学,2015,23(7):152-158.
[20] Drake D F,Kleindorfer P R,Van Wassenhove L N. Technology choice and capacity portfolios under emissions regulation[J]. Production and Operations Management,2016,25(6):1006-1025.
[21] 但斌,丁雪峰. 再制造品最优定价及市场挤兑与市场增长效应分析[J]. 系统工程理论与实践,2010,30(8):1371-1379.