循环供应链管理研究发展与展望

doi:10.16381/j.cnki.issn1003-207x.2024.1616

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

为应对全球资源紧缺和环境污染带来的双重挑战，循环供应链管理已经成为各国政府倡导和企业实施的重要实践。根据已有文献和企业实践，本文提出循环供应链管理研究的分析框架。基于该框架，本文使用文献计量分析的方法，收集来自12种运营管理领域权威期刊的898篇英文文献的数据，对所选文献的关键词进行词频分析、共现分析和聚类分析。基于分析结果，本文总结梳理出循环供应链管理研究的发展历程，即：从内部运营到供应链协同，“从逆向物流、闭环供应链到循环供应链，以及新研究主题（数字技术应用、供应链韧性、中国实践）的涌现。最后，本文提出四个未来可能的重点研究方向，即：报废产品开环回收、循环供应链网络协同和生态系统、数字技术在循环供应链管理中的应用和循环供应链韧性。以期能为其他研究者提供参考，并给实践发展带来启示。

关键词: 循环供应链管理, 文献计量分析, 数字技术, 供应链韧性

Abstract:

To address the challenges of global resource scarcity and environmental pollution， circular supply chain management has become an important practice promoted by governments and implemented by enterprises. Based on the existing literature and enterprises’practices， an analytical framework is proposed for circular supply chain management research. Using this framework， the bibliometric analysis is applied using data collected from 898 English sample articles in 12 prestigious journals in the field of operations management， to conduct frequency analysis， co-word analysis and clustering of keywords. Based on analysis results， the evolution of circular supply chain management research is summarized， namely： ‘from internal operation to supply chain-wide coordination’，‘from reverse logistics and closed-loop supply chain to circular supply chain’ and ‘the emergence of new research themes （applications of digital technologies， supply chain resilience， Chinese practices）’. Finally， four possible future research directions are presented， namely： ‘open-loop recycling of end-of-life products’， ‘circular supply chain network collaborations and ecosystems’，‘application of digital technology in circular supply chain management’ and ‘circular supply chain resilience’.Some implications are provided for other researchers and it brings insights to the development of circular supply chain management practices in this study.

Key words: circular supply chain management, bibliometric analysis, digital technology, supply chain resilience

中图分类号:

C931.2

朱庆华, 陈宇潇, 陈国玉. 循环供应链管理研究发展与展望[J]. 中国管理科学, 2025, 33(1): 221-231.

Qinghua Zhu, Yuxiao Chen, Guoyu Chen. The Evolution and Prospects of Research on Circular Supply Chain Management[J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2025, 33(1): 221-231.

图/表 8

图1

图2

表1

表2

图3

表3

图4

表4

参考文献 61

1	Govindan K， Hasanagic M. A systematic review on drivers， barriers， and practices towards circular economy： A supply chain perspective［J］. International Journal of Production Research， 2018， 56（1-2）： 278-311.
2	Zhang A， Wang J X， Farooque M， et al. Multi-dimensional circular supply chain management： A comparative review of the state-of-the-art practices and research［J］. Transportation Research Part E： Logistics and Transportation Review， 2021， 155：102509.
3	Farooque M， Zhang A， Liu Y， et al. Circular supply chain management： Performance outcomes and the role of eco-industrial parks in China［J］. Transportation Research Part E： Logistics and Transportation Review， 2022， 157：102596.
4	Commission European. Restriction of hazardous substances in electrical and electronic equipment （RoHS）［EB/OL］.［2024-09-06］. .
5	Commission European. Waste from electrical and electronic equipment （WEEE）［EB/OL］.［2024-09-06］. .
6	Commission European.Packaging waste［EB/OL］.［2024-09-06］..
7	Zhu Q， Sarkis J， Lai K H. An institutional theoretic investigation on the links between internationalization of Chinese manufacturers and their environmental supply Chain management［J］. Resources Conservation and Recycling， 2011， 55（6）： 623-630.
8	光明日报. “十四五”时期我国将大力发展循环经济［EB/OL］.（2021-07-08）［2024-08-29］. .
	Daily Guangming. China will vigorously promote circular economy during the ‘14th five-year plan’period［EB/OL］. （2021-07-08）［2024-08-29］. .
9	资源节约和环境保护司. 国家发展改革委关于印发“十四五”循环经济发展规划的通知［EB/OL］.（2021-07-07）［2024-09-06］..
	Department of Resource Conservation and environmental protection. Issuance by the national development and reform commission of the circular economy development plan during the ‘14th five-year plan’period［EB/OL］. （2021-07-07）［2024-09-06］. .
10	新华社. 中共中央国务院关于加快经济社会发展全面绿色转型的意见［EB/OL］.（2024-08-11）［2024-09-10］. .
	Xinhua News Agency. Opinions of the communist party of China central committee and the state council on accelerating the comprehensive green transformation of economic and social development［EB/OL］. （2024-08-11）［2024-09-10］. .
11	Bleischwitz R， Yang M， Huang B， et al. The circular economy in China： Achievements， challenges and potential implications for decarbonization［J］. Resources， Conservation and Recycling， 2022， 183：106350.
12	Farooque M， Zhang A， Thürer M， et al. Circular supply chain management： A definition and structured literature review［J］. Journal of Cleaner Production， 2019， 228：882-900.
13	Zhang A， Duong L， Seuring S， et al. Circular supply chain management： A bibliometric analysis-based literature review［J］. The International Journal of Logistics Management， 2023， 34（3）：847-872.
14	Zhu Q， Sarkis J. Relationships between operational practices and performance among early adopters of green supply chain management practices in Chinese manufacturing enterprises［J］. Journal of Operations Management， 2004， 22（3）：265-289.
15	Genovese A， Acquaye A A， Figueroa A， et al. Sustainable supply chain management and the transition towards a circular economy： Evidence and some applications［J］. Omega， 2017， 66：344-357.
16	Gunasekara L， Robb D J， Zhang A. Used product acquisition， sorting and disposition for circular supply chains： Literature review and research directions［J］. International Journal of Production Economics， 2023， 260：108844.
17	Shen L， Worrell E， Patel M K. Open-loop recycling： A LCA case study of PET bottle-to-fibre recycling［J］. Resources， Conservation and Recycling， 2010， 55（1）：34-52.
18	刘军军，冯云婷，朱庆华. 可持续运营管理研究趋势和展望［J］. 系统工程理论与实践， 2020， 40（8）： 1996-2007.
	Liu J J， Feng Y T， Zhu Q H. The research trend and future directions on sustainable operations management［J］. Systems Engineering-Theory & Practice， 2020， 40（8）： 1996-2007.
19	Wei J， Liang G， Alex J， et al. Research progress of energy utilization of agricultural waste in China： Bibliometric analysis by citespace［J］. Sustainability， 2020， 12（3）：812.
20	Hu C P， Hu J M， Deng S L， et al. A co-word analysis of library and information science in China［J］. Scientometrics， 2013， 97：369-382.
21	An X Y， Wu Q Q. Co-word analysis of the trends in stem cells field based on subject heading weighting［J］. Scientometrics， 2011， 88（1）： 133-144.
22	赵蓉英，许丽敏. 文献计量学发展演进与研究前沿的知识图谱探析［J］. 中国图书馆学报， 2010， 36（5）： 60-68.
	Zhao R Y， Xu L M. The knowledge map of the evolution and research frontiers of the bibliometrics［J］. Journal of Library Science in China， 2010， 36（5）： 60-68.
23	Esmaeili M， Allameh G， Tajvidi T. Using game theory for analysing pricing models in closed-loop supply chain from short-and long-term perspectives［J］. International Journal of Production Research， 2016， 54（7）：2152-2169.
24	Cambrosio A， Limoges C， Courtial J P， et al. Historical scientometrics？ Mapping over 70 years of biological safety research with co-word analysis［J］. Scientometrics， 1993， 27（2）：119-143.
25	Chai K H， Xiao X. Understanding design research： A bibliometric analysis of design studies（1996-2010）［J］. Design Studies， 2012， 33（1）： 24-43.
26	Bressanelli G， Perona M， Saccani N. Challenges in supply chain redesign for the circular economy： A literature review and a multiple case study［J］. International Journal of Production Research， 2019， 57（23）：7395-7422.
27	Farooque M， Zhang A， Liu Y. Barriers to circular food supply chains in China［J］. Supply Chain Management： An International Journal， 2019， 24（5）：677-696.
28	Zhang Y， He Y， Yue J， et al. Pricing decisions for a supply chain with refurbished products［J］. International Journal of Production Research， 2019， 57（9）：2867-2900.
29	Wang J， He S. Government interventions in closed-loop supply chains with modularity design［J］. International Journal of Production Economics， 2023， 264： 108965.
30	Yang Y， Lin J， Hedenstierna C P T， et al. The more the better？The impact of the number and location of product recovery options on the system dynamics in a closed-loop supply chain［J］. Transportation Research Part E： Logistics and Transportation Review， 2023， 175：103150.
31	Shankar R， Bhattacharyya S， Choudhary A. A decision model for a strategic closed-loop supply chain to reclaim end-of-life vehicles［J］. International Journal of Production Economics， 2018， 195：273-286.
32	Hu P， Chu F， Dolgui A， et al. Integrated multi-product reverse supply chain design and disassembly line balancing under uncertainty［J］. Omega， 2024， 126： 103062.
33	Meier O， Gruchmann T， Ivanov D. Circular supply chain management with blockchain technology： A dynamic capabilities view［J］. Transportation Research Part E： Logistics and Transportation Review， 2023， 176：103177.
34	Gebhardt M， Spieske A， Birkel H. The future of the circular economy and its effect on supply chain dependencies： Empirical evidence from a delphi study［J］. Transportation Research Part E： Logistics and Transportation Review， 2022， 157：102570.
35	Guide V D R， Van Wassenhove L N. Closed-loop supply chains： An introduction to the feature issue （part 1）［J］. Production and Operations Management， 2006， 15（3）：345-350.
36	Guide V D R， Van Wassenhove L N. OR FORUM-The evolution of closed-loop supply chain research［J］. Operations Research， 2009， 57（1）：10-18.
37	Guide V D R， Kraus M E， Srivastava R. Scheduling policies for remanufacturing［J］. International Journal of Production Economics， 1997， 48（2）：187-204.
38	Johnson M R， Wang M H. Economical evaluation of disassembly operations for recycling， remanufacturing and reuse［J］. International Journal of Production Research， 1998， 36（12）：3227-3252.
39	Govindan K， Soleimani H， Kannan D. Reverse logistics and closed-loop supply chain： A comprehensive review to explore the future［J］. European Journal of Operational Research， 2015， 240（3）：603-626.
40	Fleischmann M， Beullens P， Bloemhof-Ruwaard J M， et al. The impact of product recovery on logistics network design［J］. Production and Operations Management， 2001， 10（2）：156-173.
41	Nagurney A， Toyasaki F. Reverse supply chain management and electronic waste recycling： A multitiered network equilibrium framework for e-cycling［J］. Transportation Research Part E： Logistics and Transportation Review， 2005， 41（1）：1-28.
42	Srivastava S K. Network design for reverse logistics［J］. Omega， 2008， 36（4）：535-548.
43	Östlin J， Sundin E， Björkman M. Importance of closed-loop supply chain relationships for product remanufacturing［J］. International Journal of Production Economics， 2008， 115（2）：336-348.
44	Demeester L， Qi M， Van Wassenhove L N. Plant networks for processing recyclable materials［J］. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management， 2013， 15（4）：670-688.
45	De A， Ray A， Kundu T， et al. Is it wise to compete or to collaborate？ Remanufacturing business models under collective extended producer responsibility legislation［J］. Transportation Research Part E： Logistics and Transportation Review， 2023， 179：103294.
46	Carter C R， Ellram L M. Reverse logistics： A review of the literature and framework for future investigation［J］. Journal of Business Logistics， 1998， 19（1）： 85-102.
47	Gonzalez-Torre P L， Adenso-Dıaz B， Artiba H. Environmental and reverse logistics policies in european bottling and packaging firms［J］. International Journal of Production Economics， 2004， 88（1）：95-104.
48	Kara S， Rugrungruang F， Kaebernick H. Simulation modelling of reverse logistics networks［J］. International Journal of Production Economics， 2007， 106（1）： 61-69.
49	Lee D H， Dong M. Dynamic network design for reverse logistics operations under uncertainty［J］. Transportation Research Part E： Logistics and Transportation Review， 2009， 45（1）：61-71.
50	Huang M， Song M， Lee L H， et al. Analysis for strategy of closed-loop supply chain with dual recycling channel［J］. International Journal of Production Economics， 2013， 144（2）：510-520.
51	Wang W， Zhang Y， Zhang K， et al. Reward-penalty mechanism for closed-loop supply chains under responsibility-sharing and different power structures［J］. International Journal of Production Economics， 2015， 170：178-190.
52	Do Q， Mishra N， Colicchia C， et al. An extended institutional theory perspective on the adoption of circular economy practices： Insights from the seafood industry［J］. International Journal of Production Economics， 2022， 247：108400.
53	Wang X V， Wang L. Digital twin-based WEEE recycling， recovery and remanufacturing in the background of Industry 4.0［J］. International Journal of Production Research， 2019， 57（12）：3892-3902.
54	Tozanli Ö， Kongar E， Gupta S M. Trade-in-to-upgrade as a marketing strategy in disassembly-to-order systems at the edge of blockchain technology［J］. International Journal of Production Research， 2020， 58（23）：7183-7200.
55	Wang K， Li Y， Yue X， et al. Leasing， trade-in for new， or the mixed of both： An analysis of new recycling modes driven by industry 4.0 technologies［J］. International Journal of Production Research， 2024， 62（7）： 2350-2369.
56	Hsieh C C， Chang H L. Sourcing with recycled materials： A contingent sourcing model with supply unavailability and setup time uncertainty for ripple effect mitigation［J］. International Journal of Production Research， 2021， 59（22）：6677-6701.
57	Katsoras E， Georgiadis P. An integrated system dynamics model for closed loop supply chains under disaster effects： The case of COVID-19［J］. International Journal of Production Economics， 2022， 253：108593.
58	Tsao Y C， Balo H T， Lee C K H. Resilient and sustainable semiconductor supply chain network design under trade credit and uncertainty of supply and demand［J］. International Journal of Production Economics， 2024，274：109318.
59	Wu H， Lv K， Liang L， et al. Measuring performance of sustainable manufacturing with recyclable wastes： A case from China’s iron and steel industry［J］. Omega， 2017， 66：38-47.
60	Wang S， Wang J， Yang F， et al. Determinants of consumers’remanufactured products purchase intentions： Evidence from China［J］. International Journal of Production Research， 2020， 58（8）：2368-2383.
61	Chen X， He Y， Zhou L. Assessing the energy efficiency potential of a closed-loop supply chain for household durable metal products in China［J］. International Journal of Production Research， 2024，62（24）：8952-8969.

序号	期刊名
1	Journal of Operations Management
2	M&SOM-Manufacturing & Service Operations Management
3	Management Science
4	Production and Operations Management
5	International Journal of Operations & Production Management
6	International Journal of Production Economics
7	International Journal of Production Research
8	Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management
9	Journal of Supply Chain Management
10	OMEGA-International Journal of Management Science
11	Supply Chain Management: An International Journal
12	Transportation Research Part E-Logistics and Transportation Review

序号	搜索主题词	篇数
1	Circular AND Supply chain	172
2	Clos* loop AND Supply chain	393
3	End of life AND Supply chain	123
4	Recycl* AND Supply chain	215
5	Remanufactur* AND Supply chain	329
6	Refurbish* AND Supply chain	46
7	Reus* AND Supply chain	99
8	Repair* AND Supply chain	111
合计（去除重复篇目）		898

样本出版年及数量		2000-2010（94）	2011-2016（247）	2017-2024（557）
研究领域		remanufacturing (17) reverse logistics / reverse supply chain (28) closed-loop supply chain(s) (management) (22)	remanufacturing (56) reverse logistics/reverse supply chain (48) closed-loop supply chain(s) (management) (61)	remanufacturing (93) reverse logistics / reverse supply chain (51) closed-loop supply chain(s) (management) (138) circular economy (99) circular supply chain (management) (19)
其他主题	博弈论		game theory (11) Stackelberg game (2)	game theory (39) Stackelberg game (6)
	数字技术		RFID (technology) (4)	RFID (technology) (2) blockchain (technology) (20) industry 4.0 (16) artificial intelligence (3) big data analytics (6) digital technology(-ies) (5)
	供应链韧性		uncertainty (4) disruption(s) (2）	uncertainty (10) disruption(s) (5) dynamic capabilities (6) resilience (6) ripple effect (5)
	国家		China (5)	China (2)

集合1	集合2	集合3	集合4	集合5	集合6
Circular economy	Carbon emissions	Channel coordination	Algorithms	Blockchain technology	Disruptions
Circular supply chain	Competitive strategy	Consumer returns	Benders decomposition	Determinants	Dynamics
Closed-loop supply chain	Game theory	Disposal	Disassembly line balancing	E-waste	Flexibility
Corporate social responsibility	Government subsidy	Inventory control	Facility location	Economics	Incentives
DEMATEL	Market-segmentation	Production planning	Genetic algorithm	Green manufacturing	Mitigation
Environmental management	Pricing decisions	Remanufacturing	Mathematical programming	Perceptions	Resilience
Green supply chain management	Production decisions	Recovery	Mixed integer programming	Recycling	Ripple effect
Industrial symbiosis	Return policy	Refurbishing	Multiobjective optimization	Retailers	Risk
Literature review	Reward-penalty mechanism	Repair	Robust optimization	Sustainable manufacturing	Supply chain
Life cycle assessment	Stackelberg game	Reverse logistics	Stochastic programming	Waste management	Trust

[1]	李博, 秦勇, 徐泽水. 管理科学领域研究现状与热点前沿的动态追踪[J]. 中国管理科学, 2023, 31(7): 276-286.
[2]	盛昭瀚, 王海燕, 胡志华. 供应链韧性：适应复杂性——基于复杂系统管理视角[J]. 中国管理科学, 2022, 30(11): 1-7.