Chinese Journal of Management Science >
2025 , Vol. 33 >Issue 2: 38 - 49
DOI: https://doi.org/10.16381/j.cnki.issn1003-207x.2021.1412
A Study on Chinese Analyst Reports Validity: Specific Information and Limited Investor Attention
Received date: 2021-07-17
Revised date: 2021-10-19
Online published: 2025-03-06
Despite that Chinese financial analyst industry has grown rapidly in a short period of time， it still faces challenges by investors to the validity of analyst reports. One possible reason is that investors cannot effectively distinguish and understand the multiple types of information provided in analyst reports. There are two most important and commonly used types of information in analyst reports： earnings forecasts and stock recommendations， which have different implications for investors. While existing research mainly focuses on only one type of information， it attempts to take two types of information together and understand their differences from investors’ perspective through theoretical analysis and examination of the economic consequences of these two types of information in a unified framework. To be more specific， it looks into how investors react to analysts’earnings forecast revision and change in stock recommendation using data of A-share listed companies in China during 2006-2018.It is found that analysts' recommendation changes have greater information contents than their earnings forecast revisions. Analysts' earnings forecast revisions can provide incremental information beyond the recommendation changes. However， market reactions to earnings forecast revisions vary when directions of recommendation changes are different. In the short window， investors react more strongly to earnings forecast revisions when there is ‘bad news’ （downgrade in recommendation）. While， in the long window， investors react more strongly to earnings forecast revisions when there is ‘good news’ （upgrade in recommendation）. The above results have several implications： （1） investors pay more attention to the more understandable information （recommendation changes） between earnings forecast and recommendations due to their limited attention； （2） investors' market reactions to earnings forecast revisions change along with the direction of recommendation changes； （3） Limited investor attention behavior exists in the short term and is corrected in the long term.It contributes to existing literature by taking analyst earning forecast revision and change in stock recommendation in one unified framework. The findings of this paper facilitate a comprehensive understanding on the role of the two basic types of information provided in analysts' reports in Chinese capital market， to some extent respond to the concerns of investors on the validity of analysts’ reports， as well as help investors understand and use securities analysts' reports in a proper way.
Mengdi Ma , Shuo Li , Yutao Wang . A Study on Chinese Analyst Reports Validity: Specific Information and Limited Investor Attention[J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2025 , 33(2) : 38 -49 . DOI: 10.16381/j.cnki.issn1003-207x.2021.1412
| 1 | Womack K L. Do brokerage analysts' recommendations have investment value？［J］. The Journal of Finance， 1996， 51（1）： 137-167. |
| 2 | 张宗新， 杨万成. 声誉模式抑或信息模式：中国证券分析师如何影响市场？［J］. 经济研究， 2016， 51（9）： 104-117. |
| Zhang Z X， Yang W C. A reputation mechanism or an information mining mechanism： How China's securities analysts influence market？［J］. Economic Research Journal， 2016， 51（9）： 104-117. | |
| 3 | 魏志华，夏太彪，王慧萍. 关联交易、分析师行为与股价同步性——基于中国上市公司的实证研究［J］.会计与经济研究，2020，34（5）： 3-27. |
| Wei Z H， Xia T B， Wang H P. Related party transactions， analyst behavior and stock price synchronicity： An empirical research on Chinese listed companies［J］. Accounting and Economics Research， 2020， 34（5）： 3-27. | |
| 4 | 林钟高，朱杨阳. 信息披露监管模式变更影响分析师预测行为吗？——基于分析师预测准确度与分歧度的视角［J］. 会计与经济研究，2021，35（5）： 62-78. |
| Lin Z G， Zhu Y Y. Does the change of information disclosure supervision model affect analysts’ forecasting behaviors？ A perspective of analysts’ prediction accuracy and divergence［J］. Accounting and Economics Research， 2021， 35（5）： 62-78. | |
| 5 | Gibbons B， Iliev P， Kalodimos J. Analyst information acquisition via EDGAR［J］. Management Science， 2021， 67（2）： 769-793. |
| 6 | 曹新伟， 曾旭， 洪剑峭. 分析师评级调整与提前交易——基于融资融券市场的研究［J］. 管理评论， 2020， 32（12）： 49-60. |
| Cao X W， Zeng X， Hong J Q. Trading before analysts’ recommendation revisions： An empirical research on margin trading and short selling［J］. Management Review， 2020， 32（12）： 49-60. | |
| 7 | Cheng Q， Du F， Wang X， et al. Seeing is believing： Analysts’ corporate site visits［J］. Review of Accounting Studies， 2016， 21（4）： 1245-1286. |
| 8 | 张大永， 刘倩， 姬强. 股票分析师的羊群行为对公司股价同步性的影响分析［J］. 中国管理科学， 2021， 29（5）： 55-64. |
| Zhang D Y， Liu Q， Ji Q. The impacts of analyst's herding behavior on stock price synchronicity［J］. Chinese Journal of Management Science， 2021， 29（5）： 55-64. | |
| 9 | Hirshleifer D， Teoh S H. Limited attention， information disclosure， and financial reporting［J］. Journal of Accounting and Economics， 2003，36（1-3）： 337-386. |
| 10 | 吴超鹏， 郑方镳， 杨世杰. 证券分析师的盈余预测和股票评级是否具有独立性？［J］. 经济学（季刊）， 2013， 12（3）： 935-958. |
| Wu C P， Zheng F B， Yang S J. Are analysts earnings forecasts and investment recommendations objective？［J］. China Economic Quarterly， 2013，12（3）： 935-958. | |
| 11 | 姚禄仕， 何方， 王丽娜， 等. 利益冲突下的证券分析师跟进行为研究——基于面板数据的实证研究［J］. 中国管理科学， 2014， 22（6）： 43-49. |
| Yao L S， He F， Wang L N， et al. Research on security analyst follow-up behavior under the conflicts of interest： An exemplified study based on panel data［J］. Chinese Journal of Management Science， 2014， 22（6）：43-49. | |
| 12 | 朱卫东， 王丽娜， 沈洁. 机构投资者持股压力下证券分析师乐观倾向研究［J］. 中国管理科学， 2016， 24（8）： 45-52. |
| Zhu W D， Wang L N， Shen J. Optimism in security analysts’ recommendations under institutional investors’ holding pressure［J］. Chinese Journal of Management Science， 2016， 24（8）： 45-52. | |
| 13 | 周冬华， 赵玉洁. 证券分析师盈余预测乐观倾向：利益关联还是启发式认知偏差？［J］. 管理评论， 2016， 28（1）： 205-218. |
| Zhou D H， Zhao Y J. Is it heuristic bias or interest relation that leads to optimistic earnings forecast of securities analysts？［J］. Management Review， 2016， 28（1）： 205-218. | |
| 14 | 王玉涛， 王菊仙， 赵迎旭. 我国证券分析师股票评级、评级修正与市场反应［J］. 管理评论， 2021， 33（2）： 3-14. |
| Wang Y T， Wang J X， Zhao Y X. Stock recommendations and recommendations change of analysts and market response in China［J］. Management Review， 2021， 33（2）： 3-14. | |
| 15 | 刘燕， 朱宏泉. 个体与机构投资者，谁左右A股股价变化？——基于投资者异质信念的视角［J］. 中国管理科学， 2018， 26（4）： 120-130. |
| Liu Y， Zhu H Q. Individual investor or institutional investor，who dominates asset pricing in Chinese a-share stock market？［J］. Chinese Journal of Management Science， 2018， 26（4）： 120-130. | |
| 16 | 彭叠峰， 饶育蕾， 雷湘媛. 基于注意力传染机制的股市动量与反转模型研究［J］. 中国管理科学， 2015， 23（5）： 32-40. |
| Peng D F， Rao Y L， Lei X Y. A unified model of momentum and reversal in stock markets based on attention contagion mechanism［J］. Chinese Journal of Management Science， 2015， 23（5）： 32-40. | |
| 17 | Da Z， Engelberg J， Gao P. In search of attention［J］. The Journal of Finance， 2011， 66（5）： 1461-1499. |
| 18 | 孔东民， 刘莎莎， 谭伟强. 分析师评级与投资者交易行为［J］. 管理世界， 2019， 35（1）： 167-178+228. |
| Kong D M， Liu S S， Tan W Q. Analyst recommendations and different invertors' trading［J］. Management World， 2019， 35（1）： 167-178+228. | |
| 19 | Farrell K A， Whidbee D A. Impact of firm performance expectations on CEO turnover and replacement decisions［J］. Journal of Accounting and Economics， 2003， 36（1）： 165-196. |
| 20 | Kirk M P， Reppenhagen D A， Tucker J W. Meeting individual analyst expectations［J］. The Accounting Review， 2014， 89（6）： 2203-2231. |
| 21 | Fried D， Givoly D. Financial analysts' forecasts of earnings： A better surrogate for market expectations［J］. Journal of Accounting and Economics， 1982， 4（2）： 85-107. |
| 22 | Bradshaw M T. Analysts’ forecasts： What do we know after decades of work？［R］. Working Paper， Boston College， 2011. |
| 23 | Griffin P A. Competitive information in the stock market： An empirical study of earnings， dividends and analysts' forecasts［J］. The Journal of Finance， 1976， 31（2）： 631-650. |
| 24 | Givoly D， Lakonishok J. The information content of financial analysts' forecasts of earnings： Some evidence on semi-strong inefficiency［J］. Journal of Accounting and Economics， 1979， 1（3）： 165-185. |
| 25 | Jegadeesh N， Kim W. Do analysts herd？ An analysis of recommendations and market reactions［J］. The Review of Financial Studies， 2010， 23（2）： 901-937. |
| 26 | 方军雄， 伍琼， 傅颀. 有限注意力、竞争性信息与分析师评级报告市场反应［J］. 金融研究， 2018， 4（7）：193-206. |
| Fang J X， Wu Q， Fu Q. Limited attention， competing information and market reaction to recommendation［J］. Journal of Financial Research， 2018， 4（7）： 193-206. | |
| 27 | Francis J， Soffer L. The relative informativeness of analysts' stock recommendations and earnings forecast revisions［J］. Journal of Accounting Research， 1997， 35（2）： 193-211. |
| 28 | Kecskés A， Michaely R， Womack K L. Do earnings estimates add value to sell-side analysts’ investment recommendations？［J］. Management Science， 2017， 63（6）： 1855-1871. |
| 29 | Iselin M， Park M， Van Buskirk A. Seemingly inconsistent analyst revisions［J］. Journal of Accounting and Economics， 2021， 71（1）： 101339. |
| 30 | Bradshaw M T. Analyst information processing， financial regulation， and academic research［J］.The Accounting Review， 2009， 84（4）： 1073-1083. |
| 31 | 张然， 汪荣飞， 王胜华. 分析师修正信息、基本面分析与未来股票收益［J］. 金融研究， 2017（7）： 156-174. |
| Zhang R， Wang R F， Wang S H. Analysts' revisions， fundamental analysis and future stock returns［J］. Journal of Financial Research， 2017（7）： 156-174. | |
| 32 | Kothari S P， Shu S， Wysocki P D. Do managers withhold bad news？［J］. Journal of Accounting Research， 2009， 47（1）： 241-276. |
| 33 | Gervais S， Odean T. Learning to be overconfident［J］. the Review of Financial Studies， 2001， 14（1）： 1-27. |
| 34 | Hirst D E， Koonce L， Simko P J. Investor reactions to financial analysts’ research reports［J］. Journal of Accounting Research， 1995， 33（2）： 335-351. |
| 35 | 尹海员， 寇文娟. 基于朴素贝叶斯法的投资者情绪度量及其对股票特质风险的影响［J］. 中国管理科学， 2024， 32（4）：38-47. |
| Yin H Y， Kou W J. Investor sentiment based on naive Bayes method and its impact on stock idiosyncratic risk［J］. Chinese Journal of Management Science， 2024， 32（4）：38-47. | |
| 36 | Barber B M， Odean T. The behavior of individual investors［M］//George M C， Milton H， Rene M S. Handbook of the Economics of Finance. Amsterdam： Elsevier， 2013： 1533-1570. |
| 37 | Asquith P， Mikhail M B， Au A S. Information content of equity analyst reports［J］. Journal of Financial Economics， 2005， 75（2）： 245-282. |
| 38 | Clement M B. Analyst forecast accuracy： Do ability， resources， and portfolio complexity matter？［J］. Journal of Accounting and Economics， 1999，27（3）： 285-303. |
| 39 | Stickel S E. Reputation and performance among security analysts［J］. The Journal of Finance， 1992， 47（5）： 1811-1836. |
| 40 | Sinha P， Brown L D， Das S. A re‐examination of financial analysts' differential earnings forecast accuracy［J］. Contemporary Accounting Research， 1997， 14（1）： 1-42. |
/
| 〈 |
|
〉 |