考虑再利用的经济效益与排放效率的动力电池回收模式选择

doi:10.16381/j.cnki.issn1003-207x.2021.2731

Abstract

Abstract:

Choosing an appropriate recycling model is the key to achieving standardized recycling of waste power batteries. According to the recycling technical route of waste power battery： recycling- echelon utilization- material recycling， a Stackelberg game model with the main recycler of a new energy vehicle（NEV） manufacturer， a power battery（PB） manufacturer and a third-party recycling enterprise respectively is constructed to solve the optimal decision and optimal profit of this three recycling models. Besides， the effect of recycled material revenue on the choice of recycling model and the carbon emission of the closed-loop supply chain system is discussed.The results show that from supply chain perspective， as recycled material revenue is below a certain threshold， when NEV manufacturer becomes the recycler is the optimal recycling model， otherwise， when PB manufacturer becomes the recycler is the optimal recycling model. Meanwhile， different recycled material revenue will lead to inconsistent choices of recycling models among supply chain members， so that coordination of supply chain profit is required to achieve a long term and consistent optimal recycling model. Moreover， when the carbon emission efficiency of power battery recycling technology is high， the optimal recycling model corresponds with the lowest carbon emission， otherwise， the optimal recycling model will cause carbon emission burden.The findings of this paper provide a reference for power battery closed-loop supply chain to select the optimal recycling model and it can also assist the government to formulate subsidy policies for the material recycling chain.

Key words: waste power batteries, recycling model, recycled material revenue, carbon emission, closed-loop supply chain

CLC Number:

Jianling Jiao,Zhengtao Pan,Jingjing Li. Selection of Power Battery Recycling Model Considering Economic Benefits of Reuse and Emission Efficiency[J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2024, 32(11): 201-213.

Figures/Tables 7

参数	模式B	模式E	模式T
w	$Q e + c b - c e 2$	$Q e + c b - c e 2$	$Q e + c b - c e 2$
θ	$[A + k (- I B + v)] r s u 2 B - k r s u 2$	$[A + k (- I E + v)] r s u 4 B - k r s u 2$	$[A + k (- I T + v)] r s u 4 B - k r s u 2$
p_i	$A (k r s u 2 - B) + B k (v - I B) k (2 B - k r s u 2)$	$B k (v - I E) + A (k r s u 2 - 3 B) k (4 B - k r s u 2)$	$B k (v - I T) + A (k r s u 2 - 3 B) k (4 B - k r s u 2)$
F	——	$(A - I E k) (2 B - k r s u 2) - 2 B k v k (- 4 B + k r s u 2)$	$(A - I T k) (2 B - k r s u 2) - 2 B k v k (- 4 B + k r s u 2)$
q_e	$Q e - c b - c e 4 a$	$Q e - c b - c e 4 a$	$Q e - c b - c e 4 a$
q_r	$B [A + k (- I B + v)] 2 B - k r s u 2$	$B [A + k (- I E + v)] 4 B - k r s u 2$	$B [A + k (- I T + v)] 4 B - k r s u 2$
q_su	$B r s u [A + k (- I B + v)] 2 (2 B - k r s u 2) 2$	$B r s u [A + k (- I E + v)] 2 (4 B - k r s u 2) 2$	$B r s u [A + k (- I T + v)] 2 (4 B - k r s u 2) 2$
$Π B$	$(c b + c e - Q e) 2 8 a + 4 B [A + k (- I B + v)] 2 8 k (2 B - k r s u 2)$	$(c b + c e - Q e) 2 8 a + 4 B [A + k (- I E + v)] 2 8 k (4 B - k r s u 2)$	$(c b + c e - Q e) 2 8 a + 4 B [A + k (- I T + v)] 2 8 k (4 B - k r s u 2)$
$Π E$	$(c b + c e - Q e) 2 16 a$	$(c b + c e - Q e) 2 16 a + B 2 [A + k (- I E + v)] 2 k (- 4 B + k r s u 2) 2$	$(c b + c e - Q e) 2 16 a$
$Π T$	——	——	$B 2 [A + k (- I T + v)] 2 k (- 4 B + k r s u 2) 2$
$Π i$	$3 (c b + c e - Q e) 2 16 a + B [A + k (v - I B)] 2 2 k (2 B - k r s u 2)$	$3 (c b + c e - Q e) 2 16 a + B (6 B - k r s u 2) [A + k (v - I E)] 2 2 k (- 4 B + k r s u 2) 2$	$3 (c b + c e - Q e) 2 16 a + B (6 B - k r s u 2) [A + k (v - I T)] 2 2 k (4 B - k r s u 2) 2$
$∇ E i$	$(Q e - c b - c e) (e b + e e) 4 a + e r B r s u [A + k (- I B + v)] 2 (2 B - k r s u 2) 2 - e r c B [A + k (- I B + v)] 2 B - k r s u 2$	$(Q e - c b - c e) (e b + e e) 4 a + e r B r s u [A + k (- I E + v)] 2 (4 B - k r s u 2) 2 - e r c B [A + k (- I E + v)] 4 B - k r s u 2$	$(Q e - c b - c e) (e b + e e) 4 a + e r B r s u [A + k (- I T + v)] 2 (4 B - k r s u 2) 2 - e r c B [A + k (- I T + v)] 4 B - k r s u 2$

References 36

1	Li J， Ku Y， Liu C， et al. Dual credit policy： Promoting new energy vehicles with battery recycling in a competitive environment？［J］. Journal of Cleaner Production， 2020， 243： 118456.
2	中华人民共和国公安部.2020年全国新注册机动车数据［EB/OL］.（2021-01-08）［2022-05-12］.
	Ministry of Public Security of the People's Republic of China. National data on new motor vehicle registrations in 2020［EB/OL］.（2021-01-08）［2022-05-12］.
3	Tang Y， Zhang Q， Li Y， et al. Recycling mechanisms and policy suggestions for spent electric vehicles' power battery： A case of Beijing［J］. Journal of Cleaner Production， 2018， 186： 388-406.
4	王浩伦.基于直觉语言粗糙CoCoSo-H的废旧动力电池回收技术选择模型［J］.中国管理科学，2024，32（5）：24-37.
	Wang H L.Spent power battery recycling technology selection based on integrated CoCoSo and Heronian mean withintuitionistic linguistic rough number［J］.Chinese Journal of Management Science，2024，32（5）：24-37.
5	Lander L， Cleaver T， Rajaeifar M A， et al. Financial viability of electric vehicle lithium-ion battery recycling［J］. iScience， 2021， 24（7）： 102787.
6	Wang L， Wang X， Yang W. Optimal design of electric vehicle battery recycling network： From the perspective of electric vehicle manufacturers［J］. Applied Energy， 2020， 275： 115328.
7	Lai X， Huang Y， Gu H， et al. Turning waste into wealth： A systematic review on echelon utilization and material recycling of retired lithium-ion batteries ［J］. Energy Storage Materials， 2021， 40： 96-123.
8	Wang T， Jiang Y， Kang L， et al. Determination of retirement points by using a multi-objective optimization to compromise the first and second life of electric vehicle batteries［J］. Journal of Cleaner Production， 2020， 275： 123128.
9	Hua Y， Liu X， Zhou S， et al. Toward sustainable reuse of retired lithium-ion batteries from electric vehicles［J］. Resources， Conservation and Recycling， 2021， 168： 105249.
10	Zhang Q， Tang Y， Bunn D， et al. Comparative evaluation and policy analysis for recycling retired EV batteries with different collection modes ［J］. Applied Energy， 2021， 303： 117614.
11	董庆银，谭全银，郝硕硕，等. 北京市新能源汽车动力电池回收模式及经济性分析［J］. 科技管理研究， 2020， 40（20）： 219-225.
	Dong Q Y， Tan Q Y， Hao S S，et al. Recycling modes and economic analysis of new energy vehicle power batteries in Beijing［J］.Science and Technology Management Research，2020，40（20）：219-225.
12	郝硕硕，董庆银，李金惠. 基于成本核算的废旧动力电池回收模式分析与趋势研究［J］. 中国环境科学， 2021， 41（10）： 4745-4755.
	Hao S， Dong Q， Li J.Analysis and tendency on the recycling mode of used EV batteries based on cost accounting［J］.China Environmental Science，2021，41（10）：4745-4755.
13	Gu X， Ieromonachou P， Zhou L， et al. Developing pricing strategy to optimise total profits in an electric vehicle battery closed loop supply chain［J］. Journal of Cleaner Production， 2018， 203： 376-385.
14	Gu X， Zhou L， Huang H， et al. Electric vehicle battery secondary use under government subsidy： A closed-loop supply chain perspective［J］. International Journal of Production Economics， 2021， 234： 108035.
15	谢隽阳，乐为，郭本海. 基于生产者责任延伸的新能源汽车动力电池回收帕累托均衡［J］. 中国管理科学， 2022， 30（11）： 309-320.
	Xie J Y， Le W， Guo B H.Pareto equilibrium of new energy vehicle power battery recycling based on extended producer responsibility［J］.Chinese Journal of Management Science，2022，30（11）：309-320.
16	Zhu M， Liu Z， Li J， et al. Electric vehicle battery capacity allocation and recycling with downstream competition［J］. European Journal of Operational Research， 2020， 283（1）： 365-379.
17	Liu C Y， Wang H， Tang J， et al. Optimal recovery model in a used batteries closed-loop supply chain considering uncertain residual capacity［J］. Transportation Research Part E： Logistics and Transportation Review， 2021， 156： 102516.
18	Savaskan R C， Bhattacharya S， Van Wassenhove L N. Closed-loop supply chain models with product remanufacturing［J］. Management Science， 2004， 50（2）： 239-252.
19	陈军，田大钢. 闭环供应链模型下的产品回收模式选择［J］. 中国管理科学， 2017， 25（1）： 88-97.
	Chen J， Tian D G. Selection of the recycling mode based on closed-loop supply chain model［J］.Chinese Journal of Management Science， 2017，25（1）：88-97.
20	公彦德，蒋雨薇. 闭环供应链混合回收模式定价及渠道选择研究［J］.软科学，2018，32（5）： 127-131+144.
	Gong Y D， Jiang Y W. Research on pricing and channel selection of hybrid recycling mode in closed-loop supply Chain［J］. Soft Science， 2018，32（5）：127-131+144.
21	Xing E， Shi C， Zhang J， et al. Double third-party recycling closed-loop supply chain decision under the perspective of carbon trading［J］. Journal of Cleaner Production， 2020， 259： 120651.
22	徐颖，刘勤明，周林森. 基于博弈论的闭环双渠道回收供应链决策研究［J］. 系统仿真学报， 2022， 34（2）： 396-408.
	Xu Y， Liu Q M， Zhou L S. Research on decision-making of closed-loop supply chain for dual-channel recovery based on gametheory［J］. Journal of System Simulation，2022，34（2）：396-408.
23	Zheng B， Chu J， Jin L. Recycling channel selection and coordination in dual sales channel closed-loop supply chains［J］. Applied Mathematical Modelling， 2021， 95： 484-502.
24	曹柬，杨晓丽，吴思思，等. 考虑再制造成本的闭环供应链回收渠道决策［J］. 工业工程与管理， 2020， 25（1）： 152-160+179.
	Cao J， Yang X L， Wu S S， et al. Recycling channel selections in the closed-loop supply chain considering remanufacturing cost［J］. Industrial Engineering and Management， 2020，25（1）：152-160+179.
25	Feng D， Shen C， Pei Z. Production decisions of a closed-loop supply chain considering remanufacturing and refurbishing under government subsidy［J］. Sustainable Production and Consumption， 2021， 27： 2058-2074.
26	孙朝苑，田思源. 碳交易政策和广告宣传对供应链回收渠道选择的影响［J］. 管理评论， 2020， 32（12）： 242-252.
	Sun C Y， Tian S Y. The impact of carbon trading policy and advertising on the choice of supply chain recycling channels［J］. Management Review， 2020，32（12）：242-252.
27	范定祥，李重莲，王晓蕾. 基于Stackelberg博弈的闭环供应链回收模式选择及其优化研究［J］. 运筹与管理， 2021， 30（4）： 135-141.
	Fan D X， Li C L， Wang X L. Research on selection and optimization of closed-loop supply chain recycling mode based on stackelberg game［J］.Operations Research and Management Science， 2021，30（4）：135-141.
28	Li X， Mu D， Du J， et al. Game-based system dynamics simulation of deposit-refund scheme for electric vehicle battery recycling in China［J］. Resources， Conservation and Recycling， 2020， 157： 104788.
29	Zhang J， Gou Q， Liang L， et al. Supply chain coordination through cooperative advertising with reference price effect ［J］. Omega， 2013， 41（2）： 345-353.
30	Yang L， Zhang Q， Ji J. Pricing and carbon emission reduction decisions in supply chains with vertical and horizontal cooperation［J］. International Journal of Production Economics， 2017， 191： 286-297.
31	Qiao Q， Zhao F， Liu Z，et al. Life cycle greenhouse gas emissions of electric vehicles in China： Combining the vehicle cycle and fuel cycle［J］. Energy， 2019， 177： 222-233.
32	Jiao J， Pan Z， Li J. Effect of carbon trading scheme and technological advancement on the decision-making of power battery closed-loop supply chain［J］. Environmental Science and Pollution Research， 2023， 30（6）： 14770-14791.
33	Tesla. Third quarter 2021 financial results［EB/OL］.（2021-10-20）［2022-06-15］.
34	Venditti B. Ranked： The top 10 EV battery manufacturers［EB/OL］.（2024-04-22）［2024-05-22］.
35	中信证券研究部.2021年国内动力电池市场回顾［EB/OL］.（2022-01-24）［2022-07-28］.
	CITIC Securities Research Department.Domestic power battery market review 2021［EB/OL］.（2022-01-24）［2022-07-28］.
36	宁德时代新能源科技股份有限公司. 宁德时代新能源科技股份有限公司2020年年度报告［EB/OL］.（2021-04-28）［2022-07-22］.
	Ningde Times New Energy Technology Co.2020 annual report of ningde times new energy technology Co.［EB/OL］.（2021-04-28）［2022-07-22］.

[1]	Yeming Dai, Shuang Yu. Remanufacturing Closed-loop Supply Chain Decision Considering Retailer’s Dual Behavior Preference under Carbon Tax Regulation [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2025, 33(8): 308-320.
[2]	Mei Duan, Zhenwei Liu, Lang Liu. Differential Game of Dynamic Closed-Loop Supply Chain Considering Consumers' Purchasing Regret [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2025, 33(8): 321-330.
[3]	Wenqi Wu, Ming Zhang. Decision-making Analysis of Power Battery Recycling under Carbon Cap-and-trade Mechanism and Subsidy Policy [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2025, 33(8): 340-354.
[4]	Zongsheng Huang, Yuan Zhang, Lingkang Zeng. Funding or Laboring? Cooperative Collection Strategy Selection in Dynamic Closed-loop Supply Chain [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2025, 33(7): 262-271.
[5]	Pengfei Luo, Xinle Liu, Ting Lu, Yong Zhang. Merger and Acquisition Decisions for Firm under Carbon Emission Reduction [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2025, 33(7): 337-345.
[6]	Jin Li, Heqi Jiang, Shengqi Ding, Haixia Zhang, Bei Wu. Research on Optimal Emission Reduction and Regulatory Policies for Competitive Supply Chains under Carbon Trading Mechanism [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2025, 33(7): 360-368.
[7]	Wenbin Wang, Jie Guan. Decision of Electricity Supply Chain for Considering Emission Reduction Strategy of Electricity Generator under Carbon Cap-and-Trade Policy [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2025, 33(6): 335-345.
[8]	Feng Wang, Lingrong Zhang, Bo Lu. Research on Time-varying Path of Multi-temperature Co-distribution in Cold Chain Logistics Considering Carbon Emissions [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2025, 33(5): 290-301.
[9]	Wei Li, Yun Jiang, Yuqin Gan, Baoguang Xu. Research on OEM Provenance Selection and Remanufacturing Authorization Decision in Cross-border Closed-loop Supply Chain Based on Tax Difference [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2025, 33(5): 302-312.
[10]	Zhangwei Feng, Bisheng Du, Zhiyong Yu, Shandong Mou. Recycling and Traceability Technology Introducing Strategy of New Energy Vehicles’ Power Battery Driven by Blockchain [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2025, 33(4): 313-324.
[11]	Gaomin Zhang, Teng Wang, Yuanyu Lou, Zhongcheng Guan, Haijun Zheng, Qiang Li, Jiaqian Wu. Research on China's Provincial Carbon Emission Peak Path Based on a LSTM Neural Network Approach [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2025, 33(3): 339-350.
[12]	Yunting Song, Ruijia Zhao, Yan Xie, Bohan Su, Xinlian Xie. Combinatorial Optimization of Investments in Emission Reduction Projects of Container Ports under the Carbon Peak Target [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2025, 33(3): 351-359.
[13]	Chengchao Lv, Yanjie Jiang, Jiahao He. Carbon Emission Reduction Effect of Green Financial Policies: Evidence from the Green Financial Reform and Innovation Pilot Zone [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2025, 33(3): 360-368.
[14]	Xiaobing Li, Yujun Wang, Wei Jiang. Pricing Decision of Closed-loop Supply Chain for Power Battery Recycling Considering Consumer Heterogeneity [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2025, 33(2): 279-291.
[15]	Biao Li,Xiqiang Xia,Qiuyue Li. Research on the Influence of Carbon Trading on Carbon Emission Reduction Effect and Coordination Mechanism under Carbon Quotas [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2024, 32(8): 250-260.

Selection of Power Battery Recycling Model Considering Economic Benefits of Reuse and Emission Efficiency

RichHTML

PDF (PC)

Knowledge

Abstract

Cite this article

share this article

Figures/Tables 7

References 36

Related Articles 15

Metrics

Comments

Recommended 0