招聘和求职是人才市场上需方和供方之间的博弈过程。鉴于招聘企业与求职人才均无法充分知晓对方的需求信息,招聘网站服务商应运而生。本文引入网站简历适配度参数,构建网站服务商和招聘企业之间的广告合作模型,预测招聘企业、服务商和服务供应链期望效用。招聘企业可选定一个或几个网站服务商构建长期合作的招聘服务供应链,通过合作发布招聘广告的形式,吸引求职人才投递简历,提高招聘效果。研究发现,网站广告效应越大,越便于求职人才投递简历,招聘效用越大;网站简历适配度越大,人才简历量越多,招聘效用越大。预先确定广告赠送率或职位价格,可预测另一参数及其对应的招聘效用。通过案例研究,本文方法成功帮助一家招聘企业选定两个理想的网站服务商构建长期合作的并联招聘服务供应链。实践证明本文广告合作模型具有良好的应用价值。
Recruitment and job hunting is a game process between recruitment enterprises (RE) and job hunting talents (JHT) in talents and human resource market. Since neither of two parties can get full information from the other side, some recruitment website servicers (RWS) appeared. But few studies have addressed that how to select the best suitable RWS.
In this study, a website advertising cooperation model between service providers and recruitment companies is developed which can be used to forecast expected utility of recruitment enterperises, service providers and service supply chain.
Recruiters can select one or several website recruiting service providers and build a service supply chain for long -term cooperation on recruitment (RSSC) which will be helpful for the ability complementary, advertising cooperation,utility maximum and profit sharing amongst these partners. The recruiters and website recruiting service providers can attract talents to submit resumes and improve the effect of recruitment by cooperating and releasing advertisements. In a RSSC, different RWS offers talents resumes from different industries, and resumes matching rates differ from each other according to RE's requirements.
A parameter (ρi) is introduced for RE's preliminary judgment on website resumes fit from different RWSs. There are six independent variables:ρi(website resumes fit),xi (advertisement intensity), ri(advertisement effect), ti(discounting rate of advertising), wi(cost of vacant position), and pi(searching price of vacant position). There are four dependent variables such as yi(the amount of expected talents resumes),uEi(the effect of RE), uWi(the effect of RWS), uSi(the effect of RSSC). Supposing yi is a decreasing function of pi, we will have increasing function of ri and increasing function of xi with diminishing-marginal effect, i.e. yi(pi,xi)=ρi(yij-αpi+ri√xi). A Steinberg game is designed in which RWSs make decision first and then REs make decision. With the method, 6 propositions are found for the reference of RE's decision making.
The results of our study show that when the effect of website advertisement is bigger, which makes it more convenient for the talents to submit their resumes, the recruitment effect of RE will be better. When website resumes fit is bigger, which bringing more resumes of talents, the effect of recruitment will be better. If the discounting rate of advertising and the price of positions are redetermined, the other parameters and the corresponding recruitment effect can be predicted.
A case study is provided in which our model was used to assist an enterprise successfully select two ideal website service providers and build a parallel supply chain for long-term recruitment service. All the data are from practical investigation. It proved that our proposed model has practical application value in real world.
[1] Weinstein D. The psychology of behaviorally focused resumes on applicant selection:Are your hiring managers really hiring the ‘right’ people for the ‘right’ jobs?[J]. Business Horizons, 2012,55(1):53-63.
[2] Gregory C K, Meade A W, Thompson L F. Understanding internet recruitment via signaling theory and the elaboration likelihood model[J]. Computers in Human Behavior, 2013,29(15):1949-1959.
[3] Tatoglu E, Glaister A J, Demirbag M. Talent management motives and practices in an emerging market:A comparison between MNEs and local firms[J]. Journal of World Business, 2016,51(2):278-293.
[4] Beamond M T, Farndale E, Härtel C E J.MNE translation of corporate talent management strategies to subsidiaries in emerging economics[J].Journal of World Business, 2016,51(4):499-510.
[5] Krishnan T N, Scullion H. Talent management and dynamic view of talent in small and medium enterprises[J].Human Resource Management Review, 2017,27(3):431-441.
[6] 武涛.垂直细分是方向——浅析网络招聘的现状与未来[J].信息系统工程,2009,(4):50-51.
[7] 梁浩.双边市场视角下我国网络招聘市场实证分析[J].陕西农业科学,2010,56(3):158-160.
[8] 赵清斌,纪汉霖.基于双边市场视角的我国网络招聘市场发展策略探讨[J].哈尔滨商业大学学报(社会科学版),2012,127(6):59-66.
[9] 梁昌勇,侯静怡,傅为忠.招聘服务供应链中合作广告博弈[J].中国管理科学,2016,24(4):94-101.
[10] Ellram L M, Tate W L, Billington C.Understanding and Managing the Service Supply Chain[J].Journal of Supply Chain Management, 2004,40(3):17-32.
[11] 简兆权,李雷,柳仪.服务供应链整合及其对服务创新影响研究述评与展望[J]. 外国经济与管理, 2013,35(1):37-46.
[12] 周世平,周永务,王海娟.基于模糊聚类分析理论的旅游服务供应链服务包设计[J].系统工程, 2013,31(6):95-99.
[13] Formby S K, Crandall R E. The talent supply chain[J]. Industrial Management,2013,55(5):20-24.
[14] Maurer S D, Cook D P. Using company web sites to e-recruit qualified applicants:A job marketing based review of theory-based research[J].Computers in Human Behavior 2011,27(1):106-117.
[15] 吴江华.信息共享对供应链合作广告影响的博弈分析[J].中国管理科学,2012,20(5):98-105.