主管:中国科学院
主办:中国优选法统筹法与经济数学研究会
   中国科学院科技战略咨询研究院

中国管理科学 ›› 2021, Vol. 29 ›› Issue (1): 97-108.doi: 10.16381/j.cnki.issn1003-207x.2021.01.009

• 论文 • 上一篇    下一篇

碳配额交易体系下闭环供应链网络的生产与碳交易策略研究

张桂涛, 王广钦, 赵欣语, 刘阳   

  1. 青岛大学商学院, 山东 青岛 266061
  • 收稿日期:2019-11-27 修回日期:2020-06-04 发布日期:2021-02-07
  • 通讯作者: 刘阳(1979-),男(汉族),山东济南人,青岛大学商学院,研究员,研究方向:低碳供应链、区域经济,E-mail:liuyang@qdu.edu.cn. E-mail:liuyang@qdu.edu.cn
  • 基金资助:
    国家社会科学基金资助项目(19BGL091);教育部人文社会科学研究规划基金资助项目(17YJA630130)

Production and Carbon Trading Strategy of Closed-loop Supply Chain Network under Cap-and-Trade System

ZHANG Gui-tao, WANG Guang-qin, ZHAO Xin-yu, LIU Yang   

  1. Business School of Qingdao University, Qingdao 266061, China
  • Received:2019-11-27 Revised:2020-06-04 Published:2021-02-07

摘要: 人类的生产和消费等活动引起温室气体增加,已造成气候恶化等环境问题,在生产、消费等相关活动中减少碳排放量是业界、学界和政府等相关主体的普遍共识。针对高排放和低排放两类制造商、多个需求市场和一个碳交易中心组成的闭环供应链网络,在碳配额交易体系下,研究了企业的生产与碳减排策略。两类制造商基于政府分配的碳配额在碳交易中心进行碳排放权的买卖形成一个碳交易子网,同时,产品的买卖形成一个产品交易子网。针对所有企业成员的利润最大化目标,利用变分不等式把含约束的利润最大化非线性规划问题转化为变分不等式问题,并利用互补关系与变分不等式的等价性把需求市场消费者的购买行为转化为变分不等式,得到闭环供应链网络系统中产品交易量、生产量和碳交易策略满足的均衡条件,进一步获得闭环供应链网络达到Nash均衡状态时的条件。利用投影收缩算法求解所建模型,并给出了相关数值算例,通过比较静态分析得到了管理学启示。结果表明:供应链网络中存在企业利润目标与政府减排目标一致的情况,两类制造商间的碳交易额多数情况下是一致的,政府对不同类型制造商应设置不同的回收率。本研究可为政府和企业减排目标的实现提供指导和决策参考。

关键词: 碳配额交易, 碳交易子网, 产品交易子网

Abstract: It has already run into a common view among industry, academia, government and consumers that reducing carbon emissions in production and consumption because greenhouse gases have caused environmental disasters such as rising temperatures and climate change. Thus, carbon emission reduction has become an important issue to be solved at present all over the world. In the supply chain, the production is one of the main process of carbon emission. In practice, the supply chain is a network structure for the complex trading relationships. At the same time, in China, after several years of pilot, carbon trading market has begun to conduct carbon trading. Herein, the enterprises' production and carbon reduction strategy under the Cap-and-Trade system in a closed-loop supply chain network consisting of two types of manufacturers and various demand markets. The first type of manufacturers can be called high-emission manufacturers, because they emit more carbon when producing unit product; and the second type of manufacturers can be called low-emission manufacturers, because they emit less carbon when producing unit product. Manufacturers of the same type produce homogeneous products, while manufacturers of different types produce heterogeneous products, and there is no competition between them. No loss of generality, we assume that the high-emission manufacturers buy carbon emission rights from low-emission manufacturers, and they trade carbon emission right in carbon trading center based on carbon quotas from government, which forms a carbon trading subnetwork; meanwhile, the manufacturers and demand markets trade products, which forms a product trading subnetwork. Combining with variational inequality and complementarity theory, a profit maximization model for two types of manufacturers and carbon trade center is established, and the nonlinear programming of maximizing profit with constraints is transtformed into a variational inequality problem. In turn, the optimal conditions for the trading price, production and carbon emission reduction strategy in the closed-loop supply chain network are obtained further the conditions that how to reach equilibrium between various decision-makers in the supply chains acquired. The modified projection method is employed for solving this variational inequality. In the numerical examples, the impacts of carbon quotas of the two types of manufacturers respectively, and the recovery rate of EOL products on the equilibrium states and the profits of enterprises are paid attention to. Thus, several conclusions with certain reference value are deduced by analyzing the changing of relevant parameters. The results show that there is consistency between enterprise profit target and government emission reduction target under some conditions. The carbon trading volume of the two types of manufacturers is the same in most cases, but when the carbon quota increases to a certain extent, there may be inconsistencies; it is not feasible to set the same recovery rate for different types of manufacturers, the manufacturer's actual recovery rate may be higher than the government's minimum recovery rate. The research in this paper analyzes the production and carbon trading strategy of enterprises considering the competition of the closed-loop supply chain network, which enriches the carbon trading theory and expands the research scope of supply chain network. The background and models of carbon trading in this paper have enabled us to deepen our understanding of Cap-and-Trade system. In the background of green development, this study provides certain instructions and reference for government and enterprises to achieve the goal of carbon reduction.

Key words: cap-and-trade, carbon trading subnet, product transaction subnet

中图分类号: