主管:中国科学院
主办:中国优选法统筹法与经济数学研究会
   中国科学院科技战略咨询研究院

中国管理科学 ›› 2021, Vol. 29 ›› Issue (9): 236-248.doi: 10.16381/j.cnki.issn1003-207x.2020.1317

• 论文 • 上一篇    

基于制度逻辑的不同上下级关系对员工创新行为的差异化影响机制研究

邓玉林1, 吴洁1, 达庆利2   

  1. 1. 河海大学商学院, 江苏 南京 211100;
    2. 东南大学经济管理学院, 江苏 南京 211189
  • 收稿日期:2020-07-10 修回日期:2020-11-18 出版日期:2021-09-20 发布日期:2021-09-20
  • 通讯作者: 邓玉林(1974-),男(汉族),江西九江人,河海大学商学院,教授,硕士生导师,博士,研究方向:组织变革与人力资源管理,E-mail:yulin_d@163.com. E-mail:yulin_d@163.com
  • 基金资助:
    国家社会科学基金资助项目(17BGL093);中央高校业务费资助项目(B200207044)

The Influencing Mechanisms of Different Forms of Superior-Subordinate Relationship on Employees' Innovation Behaviors: A Perspective of Multiple Institutional Logics

DENG Yu-lin1, WU Jie1, DA Qing-li2   

  1. 1. Business School of Hohai University, Nanjing 211100, China;
    2. School of Economics and Management, Southeast University, Nanjing 211189, China
  • Received:2020-07-10 Revised:2020-11-18 Online:2021-09-20 Published:2021-09-20

摘要: 作为组织中影响员工创新的重要人际关系,层级性上下级关系目前存在着基于西方文化的LMX (领导-成员交换)与基于中国文化的SSG (上司-下属关系)两种界定。为探求不同上下级关系对员工创新行为的影响机制是否有所不同,本研究从制度逻辑视角出发,基于社会交换理论和制度逻辑二维分析框架,构建了上下级关系透过心理授权作用于员工创新行为的路径,剖析了SSG和LMX对创新行为的差异化影响机制。来自72个团队的252名成员为样本的实证分析表明,SSG和LMX均能正向影响员工创新行为,心理授权在这种影响中均发挥着中介作用;尤为重要的是,相较于基于工作逻辑的LMX,基于家族逻辑的SSG对中国情境下的员工创新行为有更强的解释力度,这种差异是通过两者的不同交换逻辑对心理授权的不同影响而产生的。本研究为解构中国情境下的创新行为和上下级互动及其关系提供了全新的理论视角,丰富了本土化的创新管理研究。

关键词: 上司-下属关系, 领导-成员交换, 制度逻辑, 心理授权, 创新行为

Abstract: Under the circumstances of innovation development in China, the employees' innovation behaviors are chosen as the research topic. From the perspective of institutional logic, a two-dimensional analysis framework was constructed according to institutional factors and institutional order. Based on the social exchange theory, by using the two-dimensional analysis framework, a model concerning superior-subordinate relationship, psychological empowerment and innovation behaviors is put forward and the influencing mechanism of superior-subordinate relationship on employees' innovation behaviors is tested empirically.
Firstly, based on two different forms of superior-subordinate relationship, that is, LMX (leader-member exchange) from Western culture and SSG (Supervisor-Subordinate Guanxi) from Chinese culture, the basic viewpoints of cognition and behavior are shaped according to institutional factors; and based on social exchange theory, the impact of different superior-subordinate relationship on subordinates' innovative behaviors is explored. Secondly, based on the logic of shaping cognition and behavior according to preferences and interests, the mediating effect of psychological empowerment between superior-subordinate relationship and employees' innovation behaviors is tested. Finally, from the perspective of multiple institutional logic, the different influence mechanisms of SSG and LMX on employees' innovative behaviors are explained based on work logic and family logic in order to understand the difference between two kinds of superior-subordinate relationship, and the difference of their influencing mechanisms on employees' innovation behaviors is distinguished.
The sample is 252 employees in 72 teams from some manufacture, research and development, engineering and software companies in Nanjing and Suzhou of China. Based on the data analysis, it is found that both SSG and LMX had a positive effect on employees' innovative behaviors and psychological empowerment mediated the above positive effects. Notably, SSG based on the family logic in the Chinese context has a stronger explanation on employees' innovative behaviors than LMX based on the work logic. The difference is caused by the influence of different superior-subordinate interactive logic on psychological authorization.
The contribution of this research includes four points. Firstly, the current research about Chinese superior-subordinate relationship mainly concentrated on SSG itself. There are few studies concentrating on the comparision of different kinds of superior-subordinate relationship and their different influencing mechanisms on innovation behaviors. And there are fewer studies exploring the principles underlying the above mechanisms. The different forms of superior-subordinate relationship from LMX and SSG and their different influencing mechanism on employees' innovative behaviors are analyzed, which could make up the deficiency in this research field. Secondly, the institutional logics theory emerging in recent years focuses on the differences among social structure and behaviors, which could effectively explain the differential influencing mechanism of social relationships formed by interpersonal interaction on individual behavior. Based on the two-dimensional analysis framework, the basic institutional logic behind the two types of superior-subordinate relationship is analyzed from the perspectives of exchange's purpose, content, reciprocity rules and long-term orientation in order to explore the psychological process and differential influencing mechanism of superior-subordinate relationship on innovative behaviors, which will be a totally new perspective for deconstructing superior-subordinate relationship in Chinese context. Thirdly, in the process of testing the theoretical hypothesis, by adopting the relative weight analysis method (RWA) developed in recent years that could separate the contribution of each independent variable, based on RWA-Web tool, the differences in the effectiveness of LMX and SSG on employees' innovation behaviors and psychological empowerment are tested, which could avoid the shortcomings of using traditional statistics to produce false or misleading information. Finally, the psychological mechanism of LMX and SSG on employees' innovation behaviors and the differential influencing mechanisms of two types of superior -subordinate relationship on innovative behaviors are found in this study. That is, the former mechanism is explained by the mediating effect of psychological empowerment; the latter mechanism is caused by the different psychological empowerment in different superior-subordinate context, which come from that LMX is based on the short-term oriented work logic and SSG is based on the long-term oriented family logic. At the meantime, innovation has the characteristics of long-term orientation. Therefore, the development of SSG in Chinese organizations could contribute to the promotion of employees' innovation behaviors.
There are also some shortcomings in this study. Firstly, the sample source is limited to Jiangsu Province of China, and the respondents are relatively concentrated. Future research should expand the investigation fields. Secondly, due to the difficulty of the questionnaire survey method of matching supervisors and subordinates, the sample size is limited, and more samples should be chosen in the future study. Finally, the motivation to develop different types of superior-subordinate relationship in Chinese context should be further explored in the future study.

Key words: supervisor-subordinate guanxi, leader-member exchange, institutional logics, psychological empowerment, innovative behavior

中图分类号: